I was stunned to read in Alpha Magazine, an Institutional Investor publication, that the Jewish Federation of Metropolitan Chicago had lost more than $4 million of their contributor’s money due to the fraud at Bayou hedge fund. According to Associated Press, the founder Simon Israel and the chief financial officer Dan Marino of Bayou hedge fund plead guilty to conspiracy and fraud charged for their role in a scandal that cost investors millions of dollars. Before reading this article, I had never thought about how my and my family’s donations to Federation were invested and what kind of returns that they received.
According to Cliff Goldstein, president of the Amidex Israel 35 fund, “there is $22 billion controlled by Jewish Federation. In addition, there is one billion in the Reform Rabbis pension plan and another billion in the American Friends of the Technion. None of this money is intentionally invested in Israeli stocks. They might have $25,000 invested in Israeli stocks by accident. Even worse, the Federations are investing in the stocks markets of countries that are enemies of Israel like Egypt, Malaysia and Indonesia.”
Joel Demby, an official with the Investment Institute of the UJC, says, “The annual survey of the Federation Endowments is not finished yet for 2006. But I estimate the amount of money in Federation endowments will be close to $13 billion. For 2005, there was $10 billion.”
The UJC sends out a four page questionnaire to each of the 155 Federations under its umbrella. I asked if there was a question about investments in Israel. Mr. Demby said no. “It is hard enough to get the endowments to answer a four page questionnaire. At the biannual investment conference for the endowments, we do have one panel on investing in Israel. One year, Jonathan Medved from Israel Seed Partners came.”
This year the panel on investing in Israel included no Israelis. It consisted of representatives from Hamilton Advisors, Northern Trust Global, and Amidex 35 Israel.
It seemed unbelievable to me that Jewish charities would not actively seek out Israeli stocks and bonds. I asked Cliff Goldstein to explain the reasoning behind the refusal of Jewish Federations to invest in Israel. He said, “If the investment did not work out, the people choosing the investment at Federation did not want to be accused of being Zionistic.”
At first, I thought that there would be a simple explanation for Federation’s boycott of Israeli stocks. Maybe Federations were not allowed to invest in stocks, or if they did invest in stocks not in non-US stocks. But in fact, the majority of Federation endowment assets are invested in stocks. At the UJC, it is 60%. At the Federation of Metropolitan Chicago, it is 80%. 20% of that is in non-US stocks.
Demby stressed the fiduciary responsibility of the mostly volunteer investment committees. “Would you have us invest contributor’s donations in high risk projects in Israel?” Someone needs to tell him that Forbes named the Israeli pharmaceuticals company Teva a global superstar.
David Brief, the investment officer for the Federation of Metropolitan Chicago and the man in charge of the Federation’s investment in the fraudulent Bayou hedge fund, said, “If I was going to invest in a single country like Israel, I would also have to consider other countries like Argentina, Russia etc.” In our heated phone conversation, he refused to even consider the possibility of investing in Israel for Zionism’s sake. He took great pride in the fact that he was an investment professional who did not allow sentimentality to enter his investment decisions.
He did not care that the Israeli stock market has appreciated 250% in dollar terms in the last five years and Israel bonds returned 100%. Wanting to believe in the goodness of people, I figured that his arrogance was due to the superior returns that he was achieving. I was wrong. In 2006, the endowment of the Federation of Chicago returned 15%, for the last five years, 11.3%. The UJC endowment of $30 million returned 12% last year, according to Demby.
For too many Jews, Israel is a place is only a place for Jews to donate money. Most do not even visit here. To take Israel-American relationship to the next level, Israel has to be a country that the Jewish community profits from and partners with. With the daily turnover of the Tel Aviv exchange being $500 million, this influx of money will give the Israeli economy a boost.
Itzick Sharir, former CEO of IT company Sapiens, said, “Invite them to Israel and let me and other meet with them so they can experience first hand the professionalism of Israeli managers.”
Demby demurred. “This would be new mission for the UJC and I am not sure that we have the manpower and budget to take on this job.”
Someone or some organization needs to make this priority. We need to create a fund of funds with the help of an advisor that offers check and balances on the fund itself and enough diversification within the funds to pass muster with these endowments. With friends like the investment committees of the Federation endowments, the Israeli economy does not need any more enemies.
Laura Goldman is an independent commentator. Her views do not necessarily reflect those of "Globes".
Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes.co.il - on June 6, 2007
© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2007