Five Years On

As Israel, the Palestinians, and the Norwegians, mark five years since the Oslo agreements were signed, views differ on the wisdom of the accords, and their chances of success. Plus: Disappearing Jaffa. A round-up of comment from the Hebrew press.

"The event marking five years since the agreements which promised a chance of a new chapter in relations between peoples highlights a mistaken and highly risky policy. The Netanyahu government has let the spirit of Oslo go sour. The chances of rapprochement between Israel and the Palestinians during this government’s term of office are slight."

Thus mournfully the "Ha'aretz" leader of August 25 commented on the recent celebration in Norway, which Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu did not attend, of the Palestinian-Israeli agreement’s fifth anniversary.

Delusion

To Meron Benvenisti however ("Ha'aretz" August 27), the promise of a new chapter was never great. According to him, the drafters of the Oslo agreements failed to choose clearly between territorial partition and the creation of a bi-national state. Former Prime Minister Shimon Peres’s declaration at the recent ceremony, that this dilemma was resolved five years ago, only shows how deluded he and the other architects of the agreements were.

"True, territories were handed over to the Palestinian Authority, which is even likely to declare the establishment of a state on them, but the Oslo framework perpetuated the Land of Israel/Palestine as a single geo-political unit, by stipulating that control of the borders would remain in Israeli hands... Israeli control "from the outside" is expressed in every one of the Oslo agreements’ hundreds of clauses, and each one enables Netanyahu to undermine the process even while adhering to their wording," Benvenisti wrote.

Desertion

Opponents of the agreements, though, maintain that, on the contrary, Israeli control in the Territories has been weakened to such an extent that Israelis living there feel abandoned, and claim that this is the root cause of the anti-Arab violence that erupted following the recent murder by a Palestinian of Rabbi Shlomo Ra’anan in Hebron. "Those living in Judea and Samaria, and the Jews of Hebron in particular, are the most conspicuously exposed nerve that the much-lauded Oslo surgeons left behind them," wrote Nadav Haetzni ("Ma'ariv" August 28). "This week, while the Oslo peacocks strut the salons of Norway so pleased with themselves, celebrating five years of folly, the Jews of Hebron trudge about in the war zone that resulted from their handiwork."

Zeev Schiff ("Ha'aretz" August 28) attempted a balanced assessment of the Oslo accord's success. He pointed out the irony of the fact that, as Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu has been forced to accept the idea of territorial compromise, and the argument now is over percentages. Netanyahu is also likely to be Prime Minister when the Palestinians declare statehood, as they have said they will when the interim period defined by the Oslo agreements ends in May 1999, and, "if he tries to stop the train after it has left the Oslo station, he will lead Israel to a confrontation with the Arab world and the international community - a confrontation Israel cannot win, even militarily."

Mistakes

Looking back, however, Schiff observes that three basic mistakes were made at Oslo. Both sets of negotiators underestimated how violently extreme opponents would respond, and assumed that hostility between the two sides would subside before the permanent settlement negotiations were reached. The agreements were also structurally flawed, in that they contained no mechanism for ensuring full implementation of each stage before commencement of the next. Hence the process is stuck, because both sides believed it should arrive at whatever destination they each had in mind regardless of what happened along the way. The third error, according to Schiff, was not to involve Jordan, which is part of the problem because of its large Palestinian population.

Nevertheless, Schiff’s summing up was favourable. "One should certainly not conclude that the Oslo agreement is a failure. Quite the opposite. This is a positive historic turning point of mutual recognition between the two national movements in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, as long as the agreement is completed in an honest way, through a compromise that takes into consideration the real interests of the two peoples."

Popular support

The Israeli people, according to Tel Aviv University’s "Peace Index" survey for August (published in "Ha'aretz" September 2) has hardly moved in terms of its support for the Oslo agreements in the five years since they were signed. "Now, as then, about 42% are in favour, and 30% against, with the remainder having no decided view on the matter." Views on whether the agreements will actually bear fruit have also remained stable: 35% believe they will, but 40% say they won’t.


Save Jaffa

Jaffa isn’t just an orange, but, as Amos Keinan ("Yediot Aharonot" August 31) points out, "one of the world’s most ancient cities," and until the 1930s, "one of the most beautiful on the Mediterranean." Then the British commenced a process of destruction, which Israel continued after independence.

Besides the now demolished Casbah, "there were beautiful old houses," wrote Keinan, "with walled gardens. Today, all this has almost disappeared. The Tel Aviv municipality is storming the little that remains, and is about to raze it finally, in favour of projects of rapacious construction companies. The municipality hopes for a share of the spoils. Anyone who wants at least a small remnant of Israel the beautiful must oppose the conspiracy."

Published by Israel's Business Arena on September 3, 1998


Responses to Press Cuttings are welcome. Please send comments to davidg@globes.co.il




Israel’s Main Hebrew Dailies:

Readership as % of population
  WeekdayWeekend
Yediot Aharonot  48.4%  62.5%
Ma’ariv  23.5%  33.3%
Ha’aretz  7.1%  9.8%
Globes  3.5%  2.8%

The above figures are based on a survey carried out by the Israel Advertising Association in November 1996. The survey covered a sample of 2,500 people representing a cross-section of the population of Israel.


Recent Editions:

  • Unsettling Thoughts (August 13)
    Terrorist murders on the West Bank leave most Israelis indifferent, and renew the debate over security versus ideology.

  • Your Money and Your Vote (August 6)
    Israelis don't seem to vote according to economic interest. Why not?

  • Walking Wounded (July 30)
    How badly hit is Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu by the first reading of a bill calling for new elections?

  • He Who Hesitates (July 23)
    Are the delays over the scheduled pullback from the West Bank due to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s political nervousness, or to problems of substance?

  • Diversion (July 16)
    A sensational treason trial drowns out the week's real news - US withdrawal from the peace process. Plus: Pollution in Israel's waters, a year after the Maccabiah bridge disaster. /UL>
Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters âìåáñ Israel Business Conference 2018