What with Secretary of State Warren Christopher having shuttled
into the region no less than 20 times, and President Clinton a repeat
Middle East visitor during the 1993-96 period, Middle East issues played
a crucial role in the exercise of overall American foreign policy during
President Clinton's first term in office. Now however, things look likely to
change. Stung by a paralyzed Arab-Israeli peace process and by
developing friction in its crucial relationship with Saudi Arabia, the
US Middle Eastern profile could well be reduced during the course of
Clinton's second term, which officially begins on January 20.
This is bad news for advocates of enhanced regional stability, who
firmly believe that high levels of US involvement are necessary to
control the region's many internecine disputes.
Peace Process Disappointment
The current freeze in the Arab-Israeli peace process is arguably
the main factor behind the developing expectations of a lower American
Middle Eastern profile during President Clinton's second term. As
recently as early 1996, the US administration was usually ready to take
great risks in order to help keep the process in gear - witness, for
example, Clinton's leading role in organizing last spring's
anti-terrorism conference in the Egyptian city of Sharm al Sheikh,
in response to the wave of Islamic suicide bombings that struck major
Israeli cities in late February and early March.
But that was then and this is now. Particularly after repeated and
unproductive showdowns with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu over the past several months, and in the wake of continuing
Syrian unwillingness to re-start stalled peace negotiations with
Jerusalem, Washington has now concluded that the Middle East peace
process is going nowhere fast, and accordingly, that precious American
diplomatic capital would be much better spent in other, more promising
regions. East Asia, for example, where growing Chinese economic and
military muscle is providing both a threat and an opportunity for major
American companies, as well as for leading US allies in the region.
Saudi Arabia Too
Saudi Arabia is a another major US disappointment in the
region, and one which is likely to encourage a perceptible change in
prevailing US Middle East policy. Despite the intimate security and
commercial relations that have long existed between Washington and
Riyadh, the Saudis barely cooperated with US FBI agents during the
investigation that was recently carried out in connection with last
June's truck bombing at the US military barracks near Dharhan, in
which 19 American servicemen were killed, and more than 200 injured. Not
to put too fine a point on it, but senior US officials were not very
amused by the Saudi attitude.
Nor, for that matter, were they much delighted by Saudi Foreign
Minister Prince Faisal's recent attacks on Israel's alliances with both
the US and Turkey, and his associated suggestions that Washington and
Jerusalem are now involved in a devilish conspiracy to divide the Middle
East region between them. According to one US analyst who formerly
served as a senior Middle East advisor in the Bush administration: "When
the Saudis, whose skin we saved just a few years ago, begin posturing in
an anti-US and anti-Israel mode, you have to assume that something's
wrong... The prevailing feeling now is that the Middle East is old stuff.
The new agenda is the New World Order, economic trading blocs, China,
Japan, and NATO expansion. The Middle East is yesterday."
The Problem of Centrality
Yesterday news the Middle East may very well be, but the fact remains
that the region is still both strategically and economically vital to US
policy interests. Putative Iranian military expansion in the Persian
gulf, prospective Iraqi re-armament near the border with Kuwait, the
danger of a new Arab-Israeli war - none of these issues can be ignored
with impunity by senior White House and State Department officials.
Bearing all of this in mind, US Middle East policy during President
Clinton's second term may not be quite as active as it was during the
1993-96 period, but at the same time, it won't exactly be benign neglect
either. On the contrary, it is very likely to be characterized by a kind
of "plague on both your houses" attitude, as long the houses stay silent.
Clearly, the hope is that's what they'll do.
Link to Middle East Risk Report quarterly update main page