TO: The Government of Iraq - RE: Your $4 Billion Debt

Little remains of what was once Iraq's prosperous Jewish community. Iraqi authorities froze Jewish assets and forbade owners from taking them. Today, Iraqi Jews are preparing the necessary legal instruments to fight for compensation. An investigative report.

Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein's presidential compound occupies lands that once belonged to one of the country's wealthiest Jewish families. So rich was this family that in 1928, King Faisal himself, while waiting for his palace to be built, leased its splendid home for his own residence. Of the family's entire property, nothing now remains. Years of persecution, expropriation and theft have all but reduced the family to destitution. All they could do was draw up a claim, giving the particulars of the houses and plots they owned, worth millions of dollars, and present it to the Government of Israel.

In the period November 1949 to August 1952, 2,150 Jewish immigrants to Israel from Iraq made out such property claims. Altogether, they reported assets worth $35,814,576. This sum is hardly indicative of the value of all Jewish property lost in Iraq, since only 6% of immigrant families formulated claims. On the basis of a quick bit of arithmetic, using that figure as a sample, we arrive at assets worth altogether $560 million in the values of the 1950s, amounting to more than $4 billion in real values. And this still applies only to those Jews who left Iraq in the 1950s. Those who remained in Iraq after that time have since been stripped of assets worth several billion more. This was done in various ways, some of which we shall describe. Do Iraqi Jews stand a chance of ever being compensated for their lost property?

Sold for a pittance

For the moment, let us take up the tale of the family described above. The family's daughter, fleeing Iraq in 1970, came to North America, where she found employment as a stewardess with a major airline. "For twenty years I had no direct contact with my parents", she relates. "I did not know whether they had food to eat. Every so often, I flew to Bombay, passing over Iraq, and all the time I would be thinking of them.

"We were a really wealthy family", she adds. The claim documents attest that they were not just wealthy, but enormous rich. Yet her parents were left almost without the wherewithal to sustain themselves. Only in 1990 were they able to leave Iraq legally, and join their daughter. They gave an Iraqi acquaintance power of attorney to attend to their property. As far as is known, however, he sold it for a pittance.

Good years, bad years

During 1917 - 1932, when the British ruled Iraq, the Jewish community flourished as never before. The British entrusted Jews with high office, including ministerial positions. At the same time, a growing number of Jews engaged in foreign trade, and large numbers entered the free professions. Due to their migration to the cities and immigration to pre-State Israel, the number of farming families declined.

In the first years of Iraqi independence, the Jews were able to further improve their position. In the years leading up to the outbreak of World War II, over half the country's exporters and importers were Jewish. They held 95% of imports. Baghdad's Chamber of Commerce management had 9-11 Jews of 18-19 members, who were that city's richest merchants.

But things changed in 1941 (5700 of the Jewish calendar). In June of that year, while the Jewish community was celebrating Shavuot (the Feast of Weeks), a "farhoud" or pogrom was perpetrated in Baghdad. Nationalist and pro-Nazi officers and men murdered one hundred and eighty Jews, destroying synagogues and desecrating Torah scrolls. Official reports say that 240 Jews were injured, 586 Jewish-owned businesses were looted, and 991 Jewish homes destroyed. Unofficial sources reported 700 persons suffering bodily harm, and damage to the tune of $3 million.

It took the community several years to recover, whereupon Jews were again able to delude themselves that they could fit in, that Iraq was their home. The founding of the State of Israel changed all that. In May 1948, so the organisation for clandestine Jewish immigration to Israel reported, the Iraqi police instituted a brutal search of thousands of Jewish homes. "In the course of the search, walls were knocked down, closets destroyed and bed linen torn to shreds. Jewellery and valuables were stolen, clandestinely or openly. In most cases, family members were taken to police stations for further questioning, and more money was then extorted from them". This persecution encouraged debtors not to repay debts owed to Jews, and in some cases, Jews were blackmailed by their neighbours threatening to turn informers.

The organisation for clandestine Jewish immigration to Israel added: "One of the guiding principles in economic persecution policy against the Jews was to bleed them of their money and transfer it to the government's coffers by means of fines imposed by courts martial, taxes and rates levied on all government services, forced contributions collected for refugees and so forth, in addition to bribes and hush money".

Season of harsh edicts

The season of Purim (the Feast of Lots) in the year 5710 (1950) came to assume baleful significance in the annals of Iraqi Jewry. In his memoirs, Mordechai Ben-Porat quotes a famous cablegram he sent to Israel on March 3, 1950: "We may well burst out weeping on seeing the fruit of our toil and the toil of those who went before us. The redemption of this unfortunate Jewish community has arrived. The government has resolved, by majority vote, to permit Jews to leave". But even as it gave its permission, the Iraqi government also debated a bill for the revocation of citizenship. This bill provided that the Cabinet was entitled to revoke the citizenship of any Jew wishing to leave Iraq. Thus, anyone putting his signature to an emigration application form would lose his citizenship. The bill also provided that the Minister of the Interior was obliged to deport any Jew who had lost his or her citizenship, such law to remain in force for the period of one year, subject only to suspension on order of the King.

Any person to age 10 wishing to immigrate to Israel was permitted to take 20 dinars out of Iraq. Those in the 10-20 age bracket could take 30 dinars, and those aged over 20 could each take 50 dinars, at the time about US $200. Also, each such prospective immigrant could take with him three summer outfits, three winter outfits, one pair of shoes, a blanket, six pairs of undershorts, stockings or socks and sheets, as well as a wedding ring, a watch and a narrow bracelet. Departing individuals had to sell the rest of their wordly goods at low prices, sometimes at no more than 10% of their real worth. The backyards of Jewish homes and coffee shop plazas became open-air markets, in which Jewish property was sold for next to nothing.

The heaviest blow descended a year later. It happened on Saturday, March 10, 1951. Rumours were circulating in the alleyways of Baghdad's Jewish quarter: Parliament was convening. On a Saturday? At three o'clock in the afternoon? For what purpose? The answer came within hours: the Iraqi government was freezing all Jewish assets.

The Iraqi government took great care not to declare expropriation or nationalisation of the assets, which, it said, were merely being "frozen". The reason was that, under international law, Baghdad would have been required, in case of expropriation or nationalisation, to pay compensation to the owners. A renowned Israeli jurist says there is no doubt that what took place in practise was expropriation, for which compensation must be paid.

"One could go even further", he adds, "and allege fraud on the part of the Iraqi government. It froze the assets a year after inviting the Jews to waive their citizenship and sign up for emigration, and then took the assets. Had they known this would happen, the Jews might not have signed up. This was therefore a patent act of fraud".

Moshe Sharett angered

The property freeze had immediate implications for the elementary welfare of Jewish families. Tzemah Menashe Nawarani and Nazem Binyamin Yaakov Yehuda, two Iraqi Jews who immigrated to Israel at that time, gave Jewish agency personnel the following account. "The spectre of starvation was fast approaching. Yesterday it was very difficult to procure a slice of bread with which to feed the children... anyone who has Arab friends and acquaintances meanwhile sells them whatever he has at rock-bottom prices, before the government can manage to seize their houses and make a record of what they contain. Money is put into concealment for the time being, until a way can be found for it to be transferred once the situation settles down''.

On March 19, Foreign Minister Moshe Sharett delivered a communique in the Knesset, denouncing the Iraqi government's moves against that country's Jewish population, and declaring what was to become the permanent policy of the Israeli government. This declaration related to the Jewish populations of the Arab states as a whole, and formed the basis for Israel's policy in this matter to this very day. "The Israeli government", Sharett said, "perceives, in this affair of robbery by force of law, the continuation of the malevolent regime of oppression that Iraq has ever applied to defenceless and helpless minorities... By freezing the assets of tens of thousands of Jewish immigrants to Israel.…the Iraqi government has opened an account between itself and the State of Israel.…Accordingly, the government has resolved to notify the appropriate UN institutions, and I hereby publicly so notify them, that we will reckon the value of Jewish property frozen in Iraq in making the account of the compensation we have undertaken to pay Arabs who have abandoned property in Israel".

Further restrictions

The situation worsened for Iraqi Jewry following the Six Day War. The following are some entries from a diary kept by Max Sudai, then living in Iraq:

June 10, 1967: "Today my Muslim partner tells me never to return to our offices. He fears we will both be arrested. Actually, I was expecting this, not without sorrow and heart-rending pain over the successful and highly lucrative work I have faithfully been doing, and in which I invested so much time and toil".

August 23, 1967: "Here amongst us, ways of eking a livelihood are steadily shrinking. Money is becoming the dearest commodity. We hardly have the means to earn even the necessary for covering our current expenses. Shares, debentures and real estate are all frozen, as far as Jews are concerned, and the banks don't make life easy for us either".

In March 1968, the Iraqi government published a number of edicts, which limited economic activity by Jews even further. Among other things, the edicts conferred on the Minister of the Interior absolute power of control over all moneys due to Jews and all revenue from the sale or leasing of Jewish property. Jews were unable to obtain import licenses, and those who worked for government or public corporations were fired. In certain parts of the country, the locals refrained from entering into Jewish shops.

Days of hunger

In July 1968, a group of army officers and Baath party members headed by general Ahmed Hassan Al-Bakr siezed power. Behind the scenes, there commenced the rise of Saddam Hussein, who controlled the party's militia and its secret services, and as from the beginning of the seventies, gradually emerged as the true ruler of Iraq.

On December 14, Iraq announced that it had uncovered an espionage ring that had been aiding Israel and the US, and whose members were Jews and officers and former senior statesmen. A month later, Baghdad staged a show trial, in camera, following which of nine Jews and five non-Jews were executed in the central public square of Baghdad.

A foreign journalist visiting Baghdad in June 1969, gave daily newspaper "Ma'ariv" an account of the situation of Iraqi Jewry: "The great majority of Jewish breadwinners in Iraq have not worked since the Six Day War... All breadwinners have been deprived of their livelihoods and their property has been confiscated... The 2,500 Jews still living in Baghdad have all become beggars, subsisting in the most terrible conditions..."

Sudai and many other Jews recently decided to flee Iraq. No reliable data is available on the scope of the flight of Iraqi Jewry in the late 1960s and the early 1970s, but one gains the impression that hundreds of families were involved. All left behind what remained of their property, frozen in the past and never released since: real estate, bank accounts and more".

How much money is involved?

What was the value of the Jewish property in Iraq on the eve of the establishment of the State of Israel? There are various conflicting assessments. These range from Stg 10 million (some $30 million in the values of those days), according to an estimate prepared by the Middle East department of Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs in 1948, through an internal memo of the then Israeli government, referring to Stg 50-150 million ($150-450 million). A memo prepared by the organisation for clandestine Jewish immigration to Israel as of January 1951 speaks of the equivalent of $450-600 million, amounting, as already stated, to over $4 billion in real values.

No one ever conducted an official census. The nearest thing to a census was the registration of Jewish real estate assets in Baghdad, conducted, in 1951, under the guidance of Mordechai Ben-Porat, chief of the immigration emissaries. Ben-Porat still retains a copy of the report, which, however, he refuses to make available for viewing, "so as not to show his hand too soon". In Ben-Porat's opinion, the time for showing his hand will be whenever negotiations take place over compensation to Jews originating from Iraq.

Published by Israel's Business Arena on 13 April, 2000

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018