A nine-justice panel of the Supreme Court today rejected an appeal filed by the state against compensating residents of the territories for damage or injury caused by Israeli security forces in the first intifada in 1987-92.
The Supreme Court ruled that each case must be examined on its own merits whether it was an "act of war" or police action. Compensation to victims would be determined upon the findings of each case.
Haifa District Court judge Gideon Ginat ordered the state to pay compensation to two residents of a village near Nablus who were wounded by the IDF in 1988. One of the villagers later died of his wounds.
Judge Ginat ruled the case was a police act, not an act of war, and the Palestinians were therefore eligible for compensation. The state appealed the decision to the Supreme Court. The question facing the court was whether IDF actions during the first intifada constituted acts of war or police acts. If they were acts of war, victims were ineligible for compensation.
Over 900 claims by Palestinians for damage allegedly caused by Israeli security forces are currently waiting for hearings in Israel counts. 30 appeals are currently waiting for the Supreme Court. Today's ruling implies that the courts will have to hear the details of each case individually and rule accordingly.
Since the outbreak of the first intifada in 1987, Israel has paid NIS 260 million in compensation in 3,000 claims submitted by Palestinians for bodily harm.
A bill limiting compensation for claims filed by Palestinians is waiting a Knesset vote. Minister of Justice Meir Sheetrit said in December 2001 that the bill was submitted in order to prevent false actions being filed against the state. The bill would place the burden of proof on the petitioners.
Deputy Minister of Defense Dalia Rabin-Pelossof said the defense establishment initiated the bill. "the state cannot permit its enemies fighting against it in an armed struggle to receive compensation for their actions," she said.
Published by Israel's Business Arena on 20 March 2002