One crucial issue is conspicuous in the Road Map by its absence future economic relations between Israel and a Palestinian state. That’s a pity, because not only does the political situation have a direct bearing on the economy, but the economy also directly affects political relations.
Up until the Oslo agreement, relations between Israel and the territories were one-sided. The territories were a source of cheap labor, which became essential to a number of industries, principally agriculture and construction. The Oslo agreement included many sections concerning the economy, designed to tighten the relations between the two people, for the benefit of both. The constant security tension, however, made it impossible to implement these sections, and they collapsed, together with the agreements themselves.
The situation today is considerably different from what it was 10 years ago. Foreign laborers have taken the place of the Palestinian workers, and it will require many years before Israeli employers regain enough trust to replace Thai, Chinese, and Romanian workers with those liable to pose a security threat. Furthermore, long-term economic relations between two countries cannot be based on a one-directional supply of labor. For the good of Israel, the Palestinians, and the entire region, these relations must be made deeper and more diverse.
In many parts of the world, the most extensive trade is conducted between neighboring countries, for the obvious reasons of convenience and cost. Such trade also took place between countries that were bitter enemies only a few years previously, such as Germany and France. Much patience and sensitivity is required, however: patience, because you cannot expect investors with bitter memories of 100 years of enmity to disregard them overnight, or even within a few years; sensitivity, because the Palestinians fear Israeli economic imperialism, and they will have to be persuaded that the aim is cooperation, not conquest.
Here is where the dilemma lies. The enormous gap between the Israel and Palestinian economies will greatly hamper true cooperation, based on mutual respect. To that must be added the tendency of many Israelis to patronize Arabs in general, and Palestinians in particular. Even if a feeling of superiority is justified in reality, it must not be obvious and offensive. If you want to develop trade and tourism on both sides of the future border, you must take all this into account.
Despite all the problems and obstacles lying in wait and the economic problems will continue long after a political settlement is achieved, if it is achieved - good economic relations with the Palestinians are supremely important for Israel. All the major revolutions in history, all the successful popular uprisings, were a result of economic hardship, even if they were not a direct result of such hardship. The more promising the economic future seems to the Palestinians, the more interest they will have in preserving good neighborly relations with Israel, and the less attraction extremist Muslim organizations offering terrorism and hatred as a distraction from daily reality will have.
For this reason, Israel must immediately begin to establish a clear position on the economic issues to be faced. The discussion should not be postponed until after the issues of borders, Jerusalem, Jewish settlements, and refugees are decided. They should be put on the agenda at the outset of negotiations, in order to make it clear to the Palestinians that we are serious, and they have a great deal to gain from a peace settlement.
Published by Globes [online] - www.globes.co.il - on May 25, 2003