Not a bubble

Mike Astrachan says the boom has started, but locals should beware the Bank of Israel.

Listening to market strategist Mike Astrachan fills one's heart with hope. But one's hand does not delve into one's pocket, and one's feet do not run to the join in the celebrations at the booming stock markets. For several months, Astrachan has been promoting his scenario about a global economic boom. He now says, "The global economic boom is not just a prediction, it's already here," specifically referring to the US and Japanese economies. He predicts that because most of the world's large economies are simultaneously doing the right things, such as very expansive economic policies to encourage growth, we're facing a particularly strong boom.

Astrachan says the rise in share prices is limitless. Under the current circumstances, profit multiples "can surge to 20, 30, or even 50. Theoretically, the multiple can be infinite."

"Globes": Does that mean that we should rush to buy shares?

Astrachan: "It was worthwhile during the past few months, but now I'm worried. I used to declare that I was bullish about the stock market in the US, in Israel, and implicitly, about the world's other markets. All that means is that in the long term, I'm very optimistic about the US stock market. But this market has been rising for a long time now, investors have become increasingly bullish, and just about everyone willing and able has already invested. I therefore fear that a serious technical correction is liable to occur sometime in the next couple of months. A technical correction is almost impossible to predict, and it's even harder to predict its scale, but I believe it will be up to 10%."

If it happens, where will the correction stand out?

"We can assume that the shares that rose the highest will fall the farthest. The shares that have risen the most are the small and medium-cap shares, which suggests that they will fall harder than others. Weakness in small-cap shares, compared with large ones, by the way, is one of the indications of an impending technical correction of the type I mentioned earlier."

High-tech shares have risen to a degree that is reminiscent of the bubble.

"There's no bubble here, although the prices of some technology shares are already as high as during the bubble era. The companies rising now are those that have business models that show precisely how they'll earn the money to justify the share price. Therefore, although the prices are high, it's no longer a bubble, and there's no reason to fear a crash like the one in 2000."

In the slightly longer term, just how high can the stock market rise?

"There are equations that show that so long as the profit growth rate is higher than the discount rate - in other words, the long-term interest rate plus the risk premium - the profit multiple should be infinite. The current discount rate is about 7%, or a long-term interest rate of 5% and a 2% risk premium, while companies' profit growth rate is around 20%; in other words, it's very high. It's therefore possible to conclude that share prices have no ceiling at the moment.

"Naturally, something will happen along the way to prevent them from reaching infinity. It might be a rise in the long-term interest rate, although in the absence of inflation and the presence of deflation in some parts of the world, I see no reason for such a rise. More likely, the risk premium will rise. That's actually possible, especially due to the risk of terrorism and war in the world. The third possibility is that the profit growth rate will shrink, which will happen when streamlining ends."

It has to stop sometime.

"Streamlining has been going on for almost 20 years, and for the past decade I've been told, enough, it's impossible to streamline more. As an economist, I can tell you that there's no such thing; it's always possible to streamline."

House sales saved the economy

Astrachan says the global economic boom is not just the results of expansive fiscal and monetary policies in all of the world's leading economies, but because all the economies are heading in the same direction. "Without us noticing," he says, "the boom arrived. The US had 8% annualized growth in the third quarter of 2003 and 4% in the fourth, an extraordinary rate for a developed economy, the likes of which we haven’t seen in years. In Japan, despite deflation, GDP grew by 7% in real terms in the fourth quarter, reflecting just over 2% nominal GDP growth, while the rest was due to falling prices. Nevertheless, this is an extraordinary growth rate, especially for a deflationary environment."

Astrachan says the US was in recession, from which it emerged thanks to the Federal Reserve Board slashing the interest rate. The US then faced a credit crunch, so the Fed again aggressively cut the interest rate to rescue the economy from that problem. Astrachan says, "This was the opposite of the Bank of Israel's policy. The Bank of Israel didn’t cut the interest rate like the Fed. At the same time, every other day, the Supervisor of Banks comes up with another idea how to prevent the banks from granting new loans, thereby forcing the banks to tighten the credit crunch."

Nevertheless, Astrachan says the Israeli economy began to grow in June 2003, as can be seen in the increase in the money supply; the halt in the slide in real wages; rising tax receipts, indicating rising imports; and other indications.

How can there be growth during deflation?

"It's possible, as Japan clearly shows. Japan has been in a deflationary environment for a lot longer, but was still able to show 7% real growth in fourth quarter. Growth can occur when its key cause is external, i.e. exports. In Japan, the factor was exports to China, and in Israel, it's exports in general."

If the economy is growing, why don’t we feel it?

"Israel's been in a recession since mid-1996, almost eight years, and when the economy is just starting to grow, you don’t cover all eight years of losses. It will take many years of above average growth before we reach where we should, and in fact we'll never reach where we could be. If reasonable growth continues this year, we won't feel any change until the end of the year."

Astrachan says Israeli economic growth is subject to many risks and difficulties beyond global growth. "Obviously, if the global growth rate slows, so will Israel's. But in addition to the global risks, there are local ones, including decisions by Israeli policy-makers.

"The greatest risk is the Bank of Israel. Under the present circumstances, when interest rates are relatively low, the Bank of Israel must not cut the interest rate too fast, like the Bank of Israel advisory board is demanding. On the other hand, it must not stop cutting the interest rate, or leak that it is about to do so, as it's done recently, either. The economic thrust is partly due to the interest rate cuts already made and partly to the expectations of further cuts. Expectations are at least as important as reality.

The second risk comes from the unions and the strikes that cause far greater damage than the workers' pay demands. The third risk is the Ministry of Finance. The Bibi effect - the public's confidence in Minister of Finance Benjamin Netanyahu - is one of the factors behind the rise of the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange (TASE), and Netanyahu has been taking crucial measures to improve the economy's structure, although he might have made some mistakes.

"But the Ministry of Finance must realize that it's now over. It must not continue surprising the markets with daring economic measures every week, because that causes systemic instability. For instance, the day before the local authorities strike ended, Netanyahu announced his new plan for budget and tax cuts."

One would have thought that you'd take a positive view of the tax cuts.

"It's unimportant if the measure was correct or not. Cutting taxes is certainly the right thing to do. But I think it shouldn’t have been done, simply because the economy had already gone enough shocks from previous measures. The economy should have been given time to calm down."

What do you predict for Israel's capital market?

"Obviously, if there's a technical correction on the global markets, there'll be one on the TASE, too. But the Israeli capital market faces a three-fold risk in the shape of the Ministry of Finance, the Bank of Israel, and the Histadrut (General Federation of Labor in Israel). If it were possible to force all three to sit on their hands and shut up, I think Israel would have a bright economic future."

Published by Globes [online] - www.globes.co.il - on March 8, 2004

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018