“The environmental problems at Ramat Hovav required an appropriate response as soon as possible. Postponing solutions for a long time is liable to damage the quality of life of the residents in the area, as well as the present and future environment,” the State Comptroller stated in the section of his Annual 2004 Report concerning the Ramat Hovav Local Industrial Council.
The Ramat Hovav Local Industrial Council, located south of Beer Sheva, includes 17 factories, mostly chemical plants treating hazardous materials. Negev residents have severely criticized the Council in recent years for foul odors emitted by its evaporation ponds, and for its unsatisfactory handling of wastewater.
Resident have also complained to the Ministry of the Environment about the Council’s handling of air pollution.
The State Comptroller’s report states that the Council had been founded in 1989 in order to handle environmental, industrial wastewater, and air pollution problems. The Council’s actions were to have been determined by the Ministry of the Environment and the licenses granted to industrial plants. Fifteen years later, it is clear that the Council has not accomplished its tasks.
The State Comptroller also criticized the Ministry of the Environment for not enforcing its ruling that each plant must treat its waste on its own premises, and for not requiring the Council to observe this principle. Furthermore, the Ministry of the Environment has set neither timetables for putting central biological purification systems into operation, nor compulsory deadlines for factories.
The State Comptroller also found that although the smokestacks of the Council’s factories were emitting gases, some of which were suspected carcinogens, the Ministry of the Environment had set no quantitative and enforceable standards for most of the materials. The Council has established no monitoring stations outside its jurisdiction, even in areas frequented by Bedouin, who were exposed to the emissions.
The Ministry of the Environment responded that global environmental standards were lacking for some of the materials. The State Comptroller said it was unacceptable that despite evidence of air pollution, the Ministry of the Environment was not enforcing suitable standards to prevent damage to public health.
According to the State Comptroller, the Ministry of the Environment should set measurable and consensual standards, either in licenses or in legislation, that can be applied within a short time. Such standards will remove the necessity for the ministry’s surprise tests, which are very costly.
Published by Globes [online] - www.globes.co.il - on May 9, 2004