nLayers CEO Gil Raanan is in the midst of his second wind. In 1997, he cofounded Sanctum Inc., one of the most promising Israeli start-ups of the late 1990s. Sanctum merged with Canada's Watchfire last month in a share-swap deal at an undisclosed company value. Sources close to the deal believe that Sanctum's value for the deal was $40-50 million. It had raised $54 million in three financing rounds.
Watchfire is a private company mainly financed by Goldman Sachs (NYSE:GS), and is thought a good candidate for an IPO next year, since its sales are growing nicely. It is therefore difficult to assess Sanctum's exit, since Sanctum shareholders now own Watchfire shares, which may yet spring a surprise.
Raanan left Sanctum two years ago and was not a party to the company's latest decisions. "I think there are people more suitable than I to talk about that deal," he says.
Raanan is already elsewhere. He founded and manages nLayers, perhaps the clearest example of the new kind of post-bubble start-up. nLayers was established as a joint venture by Gemini Israel Funds and Walden Israel. A year later, nLayers has raised $3 million in its first financing round, and already has paying customers for a working product.
nLayers develops software that automatically identifies and maps various applications and interfaces in an enterprise's computer systems. The software enables information systems managers to identify types of applications running on the network in real time, locate faults and their causes, and diagnose network overload.
In those days at this time
Raanan says there is virtually no similarity between the founding of Sanctum and nLayers. "It's completely different. When Eran Reshef and I founded Sanctum, we first set about hiring a team and developing a product, only to discover that there was no demand for the product, it had no market, and was not actually needed.
"We recovered and began again, but we had wasted a lot of time and money. Times were good then. It was possible to raise money and everything was much more forgiving. At nLayers, we began with six months joint work with two venture capital funds. Walden Israel general partner Eyal Kaplan and Gemini Israel Funds general partner Tali Aben closely accompanied us from the outset. In January 2003, we began meeting with scores of potential users."
Starting out that way changed the picture, says Raanan. "Our initial idea was information security, to secure applications without new components by using an existing system and its configuration. During the meetings, I realized that this was a bad and superfluous idea. On the other hand, I discovered a huge demand for information mapping solutions. I threw my original concept away, and went for what I heard was needed. I presented my new idea and received encouraging signs from the market. That's what the company is now doing: modeling and optimizing information centers. During the process, I met users and distributors of large US companies. The fact that I moved to Silicon Valley at such an early stage had a huge impact."
"Globes": Why?
Raanan: "At Sanctum, each trip to the US wasted a week and involved complicated coordination. When I'm there, I'm more available and can maintain connections and organize meetings much more easily. I didn’t have a team to manage. I started each day with plans for just the next few steps. This enabled us to move forward quickly, in coordination with our customers and potential competition. We built a prototype that showed what the system does and in April, we signed up five or six large enterprises that wanted to participate in the beta test. That made it possible for me to very quickly develop a business plan and development plan, as well as gather customers and partners interested in the initial stages."
Seven months after the concept first emerged, nLayers raised money, when it already had paying customers: Interwoven (Nasdaq:IWOV), a California high-tech company; People's Bank (Nasdaq:PBCT), a major commercial bank in Connecticut; and NetVision, an Israeli Internet service provider (ISP). "At Sanctum, it took us a two years and at least $2 million to install a product with customers," Raanan notes.
How did you do it?
"nLayers' product development strategy was based on thorough planning. Each component of the system is designed separately against 10% of the system, which means that it might be installed when it can perform at only a fraction of its capacity. This enables us to design a product close to the market and in accordance with customers' demands. Sanctum's customer interaction only began after the whole product development process was completed."
Raanan says everything since 1999 has changed. "Six years passed between the founding of Sanctum and nLayers. During this period, we raised $54 million and I moved to the US. But the biggest difference is that when you begin today, you know what's ahead. We didn’t know before. It was a preliminary experience. How to raise money and from whom? Why aren’t customers rushing to buy your product? The focus is completely different now. You have to give maximum results for a minimum of money. The buzz is a lot less important. Previously, there were no significant limits on the money, whereas now you have to create value.
"You're measured differently. They way you build a company is different. You don’t build a shadow-enterprise, or a development team before you have very clear market indications. The whole work concept is aimed at leveraging what is possible. You raise a little money in advance and set aggressive targets. I learned a lesson. Even if nLayers had raised more money, it wouldn’t have reached a different destination. Another $10 million wouldn’t have helped me reach the market any faster.
"Then, the goal was to be heard and talked about. Sales were less important; in fact they were utterly unimportant. You spent a lot more time on who you were, not what your business was. Today, I am building a business. I can't even make a comparison, because I didn’t think about those things then. Today, you plan more and dream less."
Is that also true about an exit?
"Absolutely. This is where the money calculation comes in: how much comes into the company and how much goes out. The entire procedure of maturity and creating value is a lot more organized and important. So is the amount of money needed to achieve a particular value. It's not a billion-dollar dream, in which it's irrelevant if you invested $10 million or $20 million in the company. You think in terms of milestones and the next 12 months. That dictates a much more logical and controllable model, both for expenditures and for expectations."
Published by Globes [online] - www.globes.co.il - on August 19, 2004