Partners in the Rabinovitch group have refused to take part in the deal to acquire 50% of the Rehovot Mall, after they learned that the mall has a Pal-Kal ceiling. At the same time, banks are hesitating to provide financial coverage for the deal, because of both the ceiling and the high 81% coverage rate required. Nitsba Holdings (TASE: NTBA) said in response that the Pal-Kal ceiling had been repaired and replaced, and the building was 100% safe.
The controversial Pal-Kal ceiling-floor system was invented as a cost-cutting method in the 1980s by then Public Works Department (PWD) chief structural engineer Eli Ron. The system substitutes the conventional steel beam, rebar, and concrete slab floor-ceiling structure with long corrugated tin boxes encased in a concrete web, sandwiched between rebar, and concrete slabs. However, flaws in the concrete casting may cause cracking and corrosion. Pal-Kal was cited as the cause of the collapse of the floor of the Versailles Wedding Hall in Jerusalem on May 24, 2001, which caused the deaths of 23 people, and injured 380.
In July 2001, a crack appeared in the acoustic ceiling of the Rehovot Mall, which is made from Pal-Kal. The mall was closed for three hours, and engineer Uri Kotai of Kotai UBG Building Engineer Ltd. determined that part of the roof constituted a danger to the public.
In June 2001, Clal Insurance Enterprises Holdings Ltd. (TASE: CLIS) filed a NIS 3.25 million claim against Ron. The claim asserted that cracks had been discovered in the concrete ceiling, and that other damage was present in the mall.
In its claim Clal Insurance added that the Pal-Kal ceiling of Hamashbir Lazarchan was in a generally hazardous and potentially dangerous state. The National Building Research Institute stated that its inspections had discovered “severe engineering findings,” and that the ceiling failed to meet the accepted standards.
Hamashbir Lazarchan was closed for a long time, until renovations were completed. The chain demanded that Ron reimburse it for the cost of the renovations.
”Globes” asked Clal Insurance today what had happened to its claim, but no response was available as of web posting.
Nitsba Settlement chairman Meir Turgeman said today in response, “The owners of the Rehovot Mall spent millions of shekels on repairing all the problems that arose as a result of the Pal-Kal ceiling. The mall is now 100% all right.” It is not clear whether US investor Efraim Shurka is aware of the course of the Pal-Kal affair.
A source close to the deal told “Globes” that banks that had been asked to provide financial coverage for the deal are hesitating to agree, because of the Pal-Kal incident. The source added that Amot Investments, which owns the other 50% of the mall, and has first refusal rights to buy Nitsba’s stake, would not exercise its rights, due to the Pal Kal incident.
The contract between Nitsba and the Rabinovitch-Shurka group is final, and does not depend on the buyers obtaining financial coverage, as confirmed by Turgeman.
Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes.co.il - on December 27, 2004