Abolish benefits for injuries on way to work, c'ttee says

Road accident in Israel  credit: Shutterstock
Road accident in Israel credit: Shutterstock

An inter-ministerial committee recommends that accidents on the way to and from work should no longer be recognized as work accidents.

In what will be a dramatic change, an inter-ministerial committee headed by Ministry of Labor director general Israel Uzan and National Insurance Institute deputy director for disabilities and rehabilitation Yarona Shalom has recommended abolishing the recognition of accidents that occur on the way to work as work accidents. People injured in such accidents will no longer qualify for payouts from the state, but will instead be advised to file a claim against the private insurance companies.

The committee’s report finds that the state currently pays NIS 6.8 billion annually to people injured at work, 2.5 times the amount paid in 2017. The number of people receiving welfare allowances for work-related disabilities has risen from about 40,000 in 2012 to 68,000 in 2022, and the committee attributes this to, among other things, a rise in the number of road accidents on the way to and from work.

In 2020, more than a quarter of the work-related injuries in Israel, 26.5%, occurred in road accidents, which compares with 22.4% in 2011.

This, according to the committee, means that an increasing proportion of the state benefit "no longer serves the benefit’s basic purpose." The committee finds that these are accidents over which the employer has no control and which he cannot prevent. 70% of the accidents on the way to and from work are accidents involving road vehicles.

On the basis of these findings, the committee recommends cancelling the recognition of road accidents occurring on the way to and from work as work accidents entitling those injured in them to state benefits. The committee carried out a simulation that showed that the damages that an injured person will receive under the Road Accident Victims Compensation Law or under the law of torts (if the accident did not involve a road vehicle) will not lead to any economic disadvantage in comparison with the work accident benefit, since the road accident compensation is likely to be higher, and any work accident benefit will be deducted from it, so that the final sum is expected to be the same as it is today.

Nevertheless, the committee acknowledges that its recommendation is liable to make the compensation procedure more cumbersome. Injured persons no longer recognized as having work-related injuries will have to sue the private insurance companies responsible for compulsory vehicle insurance, a very slow procedure. A year can pass between the accident and the filing of a claim in court, and several years are liable to pass before a ruling is given. This compares with just a few months taken to receive an accident benefit from the National Insurance Institute.

A further disadvantage pointed out by the committee is that the eventual payout by the insurance company is usually in the form of a one-time payment, rather than a periodic payment that gives the injured person greater financial certainty over time.

Adv. Ronen Vardi, an expert on work accidents, agrees that the committee’s recommendation could solve some of the current duplication in compensation payments arising from the fact that the insurance companies indemnify the National Insurance Institute for payments to people injured in road accidents. He says, however, that the one-time compensation payment is a dramatic disadvantage that takes away from the continuity of the lifelong payments that injured people currently receive. In addition, a person not recognized as injured at work will not receive compensation for loss of earning capacity from the insurance companies.

Ronen estimates that many people injured in accidents that are not road accidents will also be disadvantaged. They will now have to prove negligence on the part of whoever injured them, to pay large fees to lawyers, and to conduct proceedings that can take years, some of which will end with a loss or a painful compromise. Ultimately, Ronen says, people will continue to pay the same premiums to the National Insurance Institute, which will not reduce the amounts it collects, but will receive fewer rights.

Published by Globes, Israel business news - en.globes.co.il - on January 8, 2025.

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd., 2025.

Road accident in Israel  credit: Shutterstock
Road accident in Israel credit: Shutterstock
Eilat Ramon Airport Credit: Sivan Farag Eilat Municipal Spokesperson Russian airline to kick-start int'l flights from Eilat's Ramon airport

Russian airline Red Wings is to launch direct flights between Eilat's Ramon airport and Moscow and Sochi in Russia starting June 12.

High-tech credit: Shutterstock 8,300 tech employees left Israel after start of war

Amid increased relocation, Israel's tech workforce has contracted for the first time in over a decade, the Israel Innovation Authority reports.

Donald Trump  credit: Shutterstock Israel can't escape impact of tariffs

Even if Israel obtains relief from the tariff imposed on it by US President Trump, it will feel the global effects of the trade war, analysts say.

Shekel versus US dollar  credit: Tali Bogdanovsky US market slide shakes shekel

The shekel weakened significantly against both the US dollar and the euro at the opening of foreign exchange trading today.

Arik Faingold credit: Nati Levi Israeli autonomous frontend co AutonomyAI raises $4m

Led by Arik Faingold, the founder of cybersecurity unicorn Pentera, AutonomyAI offers a platform that learns and understands the full organizational context and generates code that can be deployed directly to the production environment.

British Airways aircraft  credit: Shutterstock/Jarek Kilian Tel Aviv - London fares to fall as British Airways resumes flights

From June there will be 20-32 weekly flights operated on the popular Tel Aviv - London route by foreign airlines - British Airways, Wizz Air and easyJet.

Partner Partner forms int'l business diivision

The division will be headed by former Bezeq International VP Global Business Nissan Arieh.

Caesarstone kitchen credit: Caesarstone Caesarstone bucks Nasdaq as tariffs boost potential

The Israeli quartz countertop manufacturer company has fallen on hard times due to Chinese rivalry but tariffs could boost its revenue.

ZIM ship credit: ZIM Trump's tariffs torpedo ZIM's share price

ZIM's share price fell 16.4% on Wall Street on Thursday and a further 7.2% on Friday, closing with a market cap of $1.5 billion, wiping out all its gains in 2025.

Israeli apartments Credit: Shutterstock Apartments sold and rented

A selection of recent real estate deals in Israel in Tel Aviv, Holon, Rehovot, Kiryat Tivon, Shlomi and Beersheva.

THAAD anti missile system credit: The US Army Ralph Scott Wikimedia US deploys more THAAD, Patriot batteries in Israel - report

Amid rising regional tensions the US is bolstering Israel's air defense, Saudi state-owned TV channel Al Arabiya reports.

Tel Aviv Stock Exchange credit: Shutterstock TASE tumbles in Wall Street's wake

Dual-listed stocks have again been hard hit, but the banks are also down sharply.

Donald Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu credit: Avi Ohayon Netanyahu due in Washington to discuss tariffs

According to news website Axios, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will be the first leader to meet President Trump after the latter's announcement of sweeping import tariffs.

Yoni Assia CEO eToro Credit: PR eToro defers IPO amid market turmoil

The online trading platform had planned to begin meetings with investors this week.

Minister of Finance Bezalel Smotrich credit: Shlomi Yosef Smotrich meets wrong man in Washington

Minister of Finance Bezalel Smotrich tried to persuade Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent to soften the tariff blow on Israel - only Bessent isn't responsible for the matter.

Unframe founders credit: Yossi Yarom Israeli AI enterprise platform co Unframe raises $50m

Unframe’s turnkey AI solutions enable companies to solve any enterprise AI use case at scale with fully functional, customized AI solutions for businesses in a matter of hours, rather than months.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018