Shades of 1931

World trade is showing a disastrous pattern last seen 80 years ago, and meanwhile governments are treating the wrong problem.

It is often forgotten that the stock market crash of October 1929 did not lead directly to a decade-long "great Depression". The market was recovering in 1930 when the U S Congress passed and the president signed the so-called "Smoot-Hawley Tariff", greatly raising US tariff rates on imported products. Other countries promptly retaliated, and international trade went into a precipitous decline. That, in turn, contributed to the collapse in 1931 of Austria's largest bank, the Credit Anstalt. Other banks around the world called in their interbank lines and caused a wave of financial bankruptcies. That was the third strike and the world economy was out, until revived by the preparations for World War II.

Recently, two analyses have been issued that point up alarming parallels to the events of 1929-31. The first of these was issued by Leto research of Herndon, Virginia. The report demonstrates that world trade has been shrinking rapidly since April, and all major export economies are now in a negative growth position, with only China in the positive column, and its growth rate has slowed significantly and continues to decline. The European Union's exports are now declining monthly in the double digits and have reached twelve to thirteen percent levels, and Singapore, South Korea, Japan and Taiwan are all now also in the negative column to varying degrees. Shades of 1930.

The second report, issued by The Institutional Risk Analyst of Torrance, California, points out that massive doses of liquidity did not bring an end to the depression of the thirties, nor did it prevent a banking crisis. In the US, since the onset of the current financial/economic crisis in 2008, trillions of dollars have been issued to banks. Now even checking and non-interest bearing transactional corporate accounts are covered by government guarantees (Transaction Account Guarantees--TAG). As a result, and since the other major central banks of the world are engaged in issuing similar floods of liquidity and maintaining interest rates at close to zero, the economies involved are awash with liquidity, but that has not led to rapid recovery to anything near normal growth patterns.

The reason is really quite simple. Liquid financial entities will not lend to insolvent borrowers, so the funds are used to buy government bonds, which although yielding very little are at least safe, and the funds themselves cost the banks almost nothing. Corporations will not invest in new plant, equipment and personnel as long as there is no significant recovery of markets, so vast sums remain idle in banks and other financial institutions, which buy government bonds with the cash. Corporate cash holdings in banks were at 51% of liquid assets in May of this year, compared with 23% in 2006. Since 2008, non-interest bearing accounts in banks in the US have doubled. The report concludes, "What backs up this whole system? Not capital, not wealth. It's just paper; paper printed by government. ...that financial nuclear explosion can happen any moment. And you will be left to pick up the pieces." Sound similar to 1931?

History never exactly repeats itself, but the fact is that for years now a solvency crisis has been treated as if it were a liquidity crisis, which is the equivalent of giving aspirin to someone with cancer. The patient feels better for awhile, but in the end it simply makes matters worse because the real cause of the disease is not treated. When the reckoning comes--and it will--the results will not be very different from the 1930s.

Norman A. Bailey, Ph.D., is Adjunct Professor of Economic Statecraft at The Institute of World Politics, Washington, DC, and a lecturer at The Israeli National Defense College (MABAL), 2011-2012 session.

Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes-online.com - on October 4, 2012

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2012

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018