Energy exploration cos are top stock picks

"Globes" looks at Israel's energy exploration sector, which will come of age in 2013.

2013 is going to be the year of gas and oil exploration shares, according to the consensus of investment houses about the sector that will lead the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange (TASE) this year. The "Globes" Big Money survey of 20 investment houses found that the three top stock picks for the year are all in this sector: Avner Oil and Gas LP (TASE: AVNR.L), Isramco Ltd. (Nasdaq: ISRL; TASE: ISRA.L), and Ratio Oil Exploration (1992) LP (TASE:RATI.L).

However, 2013 began poorly for the industry. Last week, Israel Opportunity Energy Resources LP (TASE: ISOP.L), which owns 10% of the Ishai license reported that although the Aphrodite 2 well found signs of natural gas, the gas-bearing strata was only 15 meters thick. In comparison, the gas-bears strata in the Tamar Sands, 50 kilometers southeast of Ishai, are 140 meters thick. This means that the gas at Ishai is less than previously estimated, and it is probably not a commercial discovery.

The market reaction was brutal, sending the price of Israel Opportunity's participation units down 62% in two weeks, although part of the fall preceded the announcement. The share price of Eden Energy Discoveries Ltd. (TASE: EDN), which indirectly owns rights in the license, fell 33% over the same period.

The incident highlights the importance of the response of an oil stock to events in the industry in general, and to events directly linked to a company or partnership. With the help of two investment managers who specialize in the oil and gas exploration sector - DBM Investment House founder and investment manager Shlomo Meir, who heads the DBM Oil and Gas Trust Fund, and Clal Finance shares desk manager Erez Shapiro, who heads Clal Finance Gas and Energy Resources Trust - "Globes" will examine the events in the industry in the coming months, and list the dates the should be marked in the calendar for events that could cause dramatic movement in securities.

February: Drilling of Givot's Meged 6 well

The development plan for the Meged oil field approved by the Petroleum Supervisor states that Givot Olam Oil Exploration LP (TASE:GIVO.L) will begin drilling another well at the Meged oil field by February 15. The company has already hired a foreign drilling company for this purpose. It is worthwhile following reports by Givot, because a postponement in the original starting date of the drilling is routine. In Givot's case, there was huge hype over its previous well, Meged 5, and the company's market cap soared to over NIS 1 billion.

"I think that Israeli investors have matured," says Meir about the possibility of new hype over the Meged 6 well. "After the Tamar well, every company that said that it was interested in oil or gas exploration caused its share price to skyrocket hundreds of percent. There may be gains, because people will pay for a lottery ticket, and usually when people see that there is a prize, you see more purchases of lottery tickets, and the public that wants to gamble can cause Givot to rise."

Meir thinks that Givot is reasonably priced now, like every other company in sectors such as real estate or retail. "There is a resources report, revenue from production, rising production, royalties, management fees to the general partner, and the market knows how to price the data according to a simple economic model, without the element of uncertainty. This element exists only for the future. If the well is successful, we will see rises," he concludes.

Shapiro thinks differently about Givot's current value. "Part of Givot's current value includes expectations of more discoveries, and is even built on a greater success at Meged 6. In view of everything they learned at Meged 5, the results will be better in terms of running and production rates."

As for possible hype ahead of the drilling, Shapiro says that the rumors start with the drilling, but at some point Givot will have to raise more capital, which could delay the enthusiasm a bit. Shapiro, who never included Givot in his fund, says that investors do not calculate what remains after the various payments. "Givot's super royalty is the highest of all limited partnerships, at 20%, and the private investor has to pay a high tax. After doing the math, little is left," he says.

Shapiro doubts that a disappointment in the Meged 6 will affect the industry. "Givot has no effect on Israel's energy independence, and will have only a minor effect on it."

February and May: Shemen well results

In mid-February, the Yam 3 well offshore from Ashdod is due to reach its secondary target strata, which contain natural gas. If there are no delays, in early May, the well is due to reach its primary target strata. At that point it will possible to know the rate of production of the oil discovered in the area by Isramco's well 20 years ago.

"The natural gas is a bonus, and little is built around it," says Shapiro. "We know that the gas is not from the same strata at Tamar, but from older strata, and there is no certainty that the gas production will be possible. If gas is found, it will be a pleasant surprise."

As for the oil target, the well should verify the depth of the oil-bearing strata and the possible rate of production. "If the results are disappointing, and very little oil is discovered, Shemen Oil and Gas Resources Ltd. (TASE: SMOG) could lose most of its value. We saw this in the companies which drilled the Myra and Sarah wells." (Modiin Energy LP (TASE:MDIN.L) and Israel Land Development Company Energy Ltd. (TASE: IE))

If the discoveries are substantial, Shapiro reminds investors not to forget the various costs. "Some investors multiply the price of oil by the number of barrels discovered, but you have to look at the net price, after production costs, royalties, and taxes. It is also important to understand the flow rate: the higher it is, the greater the cash flow, and it comes in less time, which will also affect the value."

Meir says that the results of the Yam 3 well could have a broad effect across the industry. "If there is a discovery, it will be the first time that there is oil in the Mediterranean, and the dream will become a reality. Investors will be ready to risk more in searching for oil offshore, and there will also be greater interest by foreign companies in discoveries in Israel. This will have a direct effect on the companies that own the well - Shemen Oil, Zerah Oil And Gas Explorations LP (TASE: ZRAH), and Gulliver Energy Ltd. (TASE: GLVR) - as well as on Modiin Energy and Adira Energy Corporation (TSXV: ADL; Bulletin Board: ADENF; XETRA: AORLB8), which hold the Gabriella and Yam Hadera licenses along the same geological line."

The coin has two faces, and if the well's results are disappointing, the share prices of other companies could also fall. "These companies are relying on the same strata and hope that oil will be found in it."

If nothing commercial is found, it will cause disappointment, and the air will be let out of the shares, because investors will think that the chances of finding oil in the licenses will be low."

Late February - completion of the Woodside deal

By the end of February, the Leviathan partners - Noble Energy Inc. (NYSE: NBL), Delek Group Ltd. (TASE: DLEKG) units Avner and Delek Drilling LP (TASE: DEDR.L), and Ratio - are due to sign a binding agreement with Australia's Woodside Petroleum Ltd. (ASX: WPL) to become a partner in the reservoir for $2.5 billion. The deal will be completed in stages, based on milestones over several years. When the companies announced in early December that Woodside would become a partner, their share prices rose, but Meir says that they should have climbed from prices at which they had been traded long ago.

"There is a problem with Leviathan, because the final Tzemach Committee recommendations for gas exports have not yet been approved, and it won't be possible to export and sell gas from it," says Meir.

Shapiro says, "Woodside took into account the absence of gas exports, and it is prepared to sign even before approval is given, but in that case the payment to the current partners will only be $700 million, which is their current estimate of the reservoir's value. The market assumes that there will be a deal, and it is included in the shares. Do not expect a rally in the shares because of the signing."

Therefore, if the Woodside deal is cancelled, Shapiro expects the Israeli companies' share prices to fall, but since the deal is subject to the results of the Tzemach Committee, he believes that there is little chance that the deal will be cancelled.

After the elections: Approval of the Tzemach Committee recommendations

Ministry of Energy and Water Resources director general Shaul Tzemach heads the committee which has set Israel's natural gas export policy for the coming years. The committee published its final conclusions in late August. It advises allowing the owners of reservoirs to export at least 50% of the gas discovered (the amount depends on the size of the discovery), subject to obtaining an export license.

The Knesset has not passed the recommendations, because of the elections on January 22. However, in the meantime, the calculation of Israel's gas reserves, on which the Tzemach Committee based its recommendations, has been undermined because of the dry holes at the Myra and Sarah wells, and the uncertain gas reserves at the Ishai license.

"The lack of a decision on gas exports, deters more foreign investors from entering the Israeli market," says Meir. "There are already signed contracts for the Tamar discovery with Israel Electric Corporation (IEC) (TASE: ELEC.B22) and private companies, and the recommendations will affect Tamar's owners less. As for the partners in Leviathan, the recommendations will affect the future of the discovery, and the TASE, irrespective of oil and gas shares, undershoots in conditions of uncertainty."

Shapiro believes that the decisions and approval of the recommendations will be made after the elections, and the big question is whether there will be changes in the recommendations in view of the disappointment at the latest wells. "There is definitely a chance that the exports quota will reduced to less than 50%, but it's impossible to predict, because there are a lot of parties which pull the matter in both directions. There is no doubt that the failure of a well is a risk in terms of export quotas from the total reserve that the committee will approve."

Shapiro says, "If the scenario materializes, and the gas export quota is reduced, this will adversely affect the pricing of the Leviathan reservoir. The milestone with Woodside should be remembered. Its initial investment is $700 million for 30% of the reservoir, giving it a value of $2.3 billion - far less than what the market currently assumes.

"Approval of the committee's recommendations in full, under the previous structure, could boost share prices, because this will lift uncertainty from the project."

April: start of gas flow from Tamar

In early April, commercial gas flow from the Tamar well is scheduled to begin. Shapiro believes that the market assumes that gas will begin flowing by this date, and it happens on time, it will boost the share prices of its Israeli partners, Avner, Delek Drilling, and Isramco, by only a few percent.

Shapiro says that Tamar is Isramco's only discovery, and that the moment the gas begins flowing, it will effectively turn into a bond. "There is similarity in terms of cash flow, and it should increase over the years like a cheap bond, at a theoretical level of 8% a year. It will rise over time, but there is no longer a significant upside in it."

Meir thinks otherwise. "Not everyone has realized that the dream has been realized, and that there is gas flow. The underpricing is due to the lack of faith in reality. They take companies with a proven discovery a risk premium that does not limit the shares," he says. He compares Isramco with Israel Chemicals Ltd. (TASE: ICL), which also extracts and sells natural resources. "Isramco's premium isn't the same premium for Israel Chemicals, and it will fall as soon as the gas begins to flow."

So will 2013 be the year of gas and oil? "I think so," says Meir. "Not everyone has realized it, but it will become a key industry in the economy, and we will see new professions in the sector. The Israeli public will suddenly discover another industry, with huge cash flows, and will see flows and profits associated with the banks and Israel Chemicals."

Shapiro is more cautious. "I think that the TASE Oil and Gas Index will outperform the Tel Aviv 100 Index in 2013, but not by much."

Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes-online.com - on January 9, 2013

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2013

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018