There is a disagreement at the Ministry of Finance over the far-ranging cutback plan by IDF Chief-of-Staff Lt.-Gen. Benny Ganz. Some top ministry officials are skeptical about the plan, while others are pleasantly surprised. The common denominator is surprise.
"There are many things that do not add up, and there is a lot of smoke surrounding the plan," a top Ministry of Finance official said. Another top official said, "The plan has not been submitted to the cabinet, and what has been published so far is only partial."
The Teuza multiyear plan was drawn up in the past few months to supersede the Oz five-year plan, which was prepared last year, but never implemented because of the lack of budgets. Following the government's decision to sharply cut the defense budget, the IDF Planning Directorate drew up a new plan to reflect the budget constraints and contemporary and future challenges facing the IDF.
The Teuza plan includes laying off 5,000 career officers and NCOs over the next three years. The layoffs have already begun. At the same time, IDF will recruit 1,000 new career officers and NCOs skilled in the new systems and capabilities that the IDF plans to develop over the next five years. These are far-reaching measures to improve precision firepower, and to expand intelligence infrastructures and cyber warfare. The Navy will continue its procurement of the expensive Dolphin class submarines and the Air Force will continue its procurement of new stealth fighters.
The new stealth fighters will enable the Air Force to compensate for the disbanding of two squadrons of obsolescent planes. The disbanding of each squadron will save the IDF an estimated NIS 200 million a year.
The Ministry of Finance was surprised by the developments, which began yesterday. Top ministry officials said that the Ministry of Defense had pulled its promise to cut NIS 3 billion from the defense budget as part of the 2013-14 state budget, which the cabinet had already approved. The sources said that the top Ministry of Defense officials had told their Ministry of Finance counterparts that they could not meet the budget targets and complete the multiyear plan under the current conditions.
Shortly after the publication of this report yesterday, sources close to Minister of Defense Moshe Ya'alon tried to claim that the Ministry of Finance's charges were "drivel", and said that Ya'alon would keep his promises. A few hours later, the IDF's cutbacks plan was unveiled. Sources in Jerusalem attributed the strange zigzag at the Ministry of Defense to "a lack of coordination within the defense establishment".
"I don’t really understand the surprise by the Ministry of Finance officials," said a top ministry source. "What exactly is the shock? After all, it was clear that when there is a need for such a drastic cut, deep changes have to be made, and there is no question that the plan is going in the right direction. When switching to a smart army, there is no question that you have to reduce the number of tanks and artillery, fire 5,000 career officers and NCOs, and divert all the resources to cyber warfare, intelligence, technological strengthening, and improving anti-missile capabilities, while maintaining air superiority."
The source added, "The moment it is clear that Syrian or Egyptian divisions aren’t going to enter Israel tomorrow morning, all the forces structure and deterrence capability have to change. Why do you need all these tanks and divisions? Is there a war on the front line? Of course not."
The top official dismissed the possibility that this was a plan of intimidation. "If they had proposed cuts to cyber warfare or intelligence, I would have said that this was populism. But to fire career officers and disband divisions - that's exactly what we wanted."
Despite the support for the Teuza plan's content, the Ministry of Finance will propose some improvements, including cuts in the rehabilitation budget and at the Ministry of Defense, and the cancelling of all procurements delegations.
Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes-online.com - on July 11, 2013
© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2013