"Congestion charge only solution for Israel's jams"

Prof. Omer Moav Photo: Niv Kantor
Prof. Omer Moav Photo: Niv Kantor

Speaking at the "Globes" Business Conference, Prof. Omer Moav of the Herzliya Interdisciplinary Center urged israel to follow the lead set by London and Stockholm.

"There will unquestionably be congestion charges in Israel, because there is no other solution. The only question is how they will be implemented, and how soon," Prof. Omer Moav from the Herzliya Interdisciplinary Center said at a session on transportation and real estate at the Israel Business Conference. "How do I know that the congestion charge solution works? Because it has been tried around the world, and the experiment was very successful. In Stockholm, they imposed a congestion charge, and they eliminated traffic jams immediately. 40% of the public supported the congestion charge initially, and the proportion of support rose to 70% within one or two years. It works excellently in London. In the Naim Layarok trial in Israel, half of the participants in the trial changed their behavior substantially. It's great that there are more railways, but the idea of getting people to switch from private vehicles to public transportation will not work without an economic incentive. Anyone in favor of public transportation has to clear the roads for it to some extent, because in order to get from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, it's not enough to expand the interurban road. I have to get from my home to the station and from the station to my destination. It's not necessary to completely stop the use of private vehicles; you just have to charge a suitable price. This is an essential solution as a supplement to all the measures being taken by the Ministry of Transport."

Moav argued that a congestion charge is a successful solution for reducing traffic jams because the demand for transportation is not completely inelastic. "For us economists, it's obvious that when a person uses a resource in short supply and its price is incorrect, it will be overused. What does this resemble? Say that Israel decides tomorrow that bread should be free. Assume that Israel itself produces the quantity of bread needed, but distributes it free of charge. In the past, when bread was subsidized in Israel, people ate more bread, used it for animal feed, and so forth. Now assume that you were born in a situation in which bread was free and there were breadlines, and I offered you a magical solution: charging a realistic price that brings the demand in line with the supply. You would say, 'What a terrible burden for the public.' What I'm trying to say is that the status quo is sometimes very strong, and people think of something as a burden."

A congestion charge is a payment for the use of the road when it is crowded in places where there is congestion. Moav says, "You are already paying a congestion charge, but it is very inefficient. For example, gasoline is a congestion charge that no one gets bitter about. A congestion charge is a much more reasonable tax, because a tax on fuel also applies to outlying areas on uncrowded roads and in places where there is no reasonable public transportation, and there is unlikely to be any."

How will a congestion charge mechanism work? Moav gives an example of a town in which all of the residents work in a factory. Every day, the town residents take an hour-long bus ride on the long road to the factory, until one day, a bridge is built that shortens the time it takes to get to the factory. "The problem with the new bridge is that it is narrow, and cannot transport everyone, so there is a line at the entrance to the bridge. How long will the line be? Exactly one hour, because if it is longer, people will leave the line and go on the bus. If it is shorter, people will switch from the bus to the line. If the line is one hour, then what is the bridge's benefit for the public? Zero benefit; the bridge contributes nothing. What will happen if people pay NIS 10, for example, for using the bridge, or it is decided that anyone using the bridge has to throw NIS 10 into the river - in other words, to waste the money? What will happen? You can see that line will get shorter, so what happened to the benefit? It increased, because anyone who chose to pay the NIS 10 and wait less time in line benefits more. They threw NIS 10 into the river, and it was a more effective regulation of resources, and the public benefit increased. Incidentally, it would obviously be better to connect the money instead of throwing it into the river, and to use it to build more bridges," Moav explains.

Moav presented data for the number of vehicles and their speed at the entrance to Tel Aviv showing that the speed of travel diminishes when the number of vehicles increases. "And then something very interesting happens. Not only does the traveling speed fall, but fewer cars pass on the road. Moderate congestion charges actually increase the number of vehicles passing - it's a kind of magic," he says.

Moav asked why the use of roads in Israeli is under heavy regulation that prevents innovative uses of shared transportation - why there is no Via or Uber in Israel. "I very much admire what the minister of transport has done about open skies, so why are there no open roads?", he asks rhetorically.

Published by Globes [online], Israel Business News - www.globes-online.com - on January 14, 2018

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2018

Prof. Omer Moav Photo: Niv Kantor
Prof. Omer Moav Photo: Niv Kantor
Dr. Adi Tzoref-Lorenz credit: Jonathan Bloom "My research says I don't accept there is no answer"

The death of a cancer patient spurred Dr. Adi Tzoref-Lorenz into developing the OHI index, which allows the diagnosis of the HLH side effect from cancer immunotherapy, based on two blood tests.

Dr. R  credit: Jonathan Bloom Wounded in his tank, now R develops protection systems

"I was close to death, but it sharpened my awareness of the products we develop for the IDF."

Ella Kenan  credit: Yossi Cohen A fighter of fake news about Israel

Ella Kenan saw online denial of October 7 happening straightaway. "I realized we had 24 hours, or we were doomed"

Liron Horshi credit: Jonathan Bloom Wiz's talent manager nurtures $1b workforce

Wiz's $32 billion sale to Google was rooted in the cloud security product if offers but could not have been achieved without the quality of its employees built by human resources chief Liron Horshi.

Yoav Shoham  credit: Eyal Izhar Yoav Shoham: AI isn't too smart, it's too dumb

AI21 Labs founder and CEO Prof. Yoav Shoham talks to "Globes" about dubious doomsday predictions, what should really concern us, and what could make Israel a global AI leader.

Insightec COO and general manager Eyal Zadicario credit: Ness Productions After 25 years of losses Insightec focuses on profit

Insightec COO and general manager Eyal Zadicario tells "Globes" about himself and the Israeli ultrasound company's long battle to change the medical world.

Amit Shaked credit: Tomer Lesher Driven to succeed but balancing ambition with wellbeing

At just 14, cybersecurity company Rubrik VP Amit Shaked began a B.Sc. in Computer Science and Math and mapped out his entire future, which included IDF service in the 8200 unit, and an inevitable huge startup exit.

Dr. Ola Gutzeit  credit: Ketty Hakim The doctor breaking new ground in fertility

"We know nothing about the female reproductive system," says Dr. Ola Gutzeit of Rambam Hospital. She seeks to change that, and hence change IVF for the better.

Google CEO Sundar Pichai  crediit: Shutterstock Why Google is paying so much for Wiz

Lagging its competitors in cloud and AI, and facing challenges to its core advertising business, Google could be looking to spend its way out of trouble.

Prof. Douglas Irwin  credit: Inbal Marmari "We will all be poorer"

Prof. Douglas Irwin, an expert on international trade, talks to "Globes" about the impact of President Trump's tariffs policy, and what Israel can do about it.

Rooftop solar panels credit: Shutterstock Does it pay for homes to install rooftop solar panels?

As the Israeli government steps up efforts to encourage homeowners to produce their own electricity from rooftop panels, "Globes" investigates the advantages and pitfalls.

UnitedHealth founder Richard Burke credit: Ken Easley UnitedHealth founder: US health system is broken

In an exclusive interview Richard Burke talks about the murder of the company's CEO, Donald Trump, his love for Israel, and investment in Israeli startup Korro AI.

Left to right: Karin Goldberg, Einav Laser, Dr. Arseniy Lobov, Dr. Paola Antonello, Dr. Merav Shmueli, and Prof. Yifat Merbl (center in black)  credit: Weizmann Institute Israeli scientists' discovery could lead to new antibiotics

Prof. Yifat Merbl of the Weizmann Institute and her team have found a natural source of anti-microbial substances in the "garbage can" of human cells.

Peter Kash credit: personal photograph Peter Kash confident about cancer cure breakthrough

In Israel for IATI's MIXiii International Life Science and Health-Tech week, the US investor talks about his life science portfolio and the opportunities Israel must seize.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018