Court orders Levin to justify inaction on appointing judges

Yariv Levin  credit: Alex Kolomoisky, Yedioth Aharonoth
Yariv Levin credit: Alex Kolomoisky, Yedioth Aharonoth

The hearing of petitions seeking to oblige Minister of Justice Yariv Levin to convene the judicial appointments committee is set for September 19.

The petitions to compel Minister of Justice Yariv Levin to convene the judicial appointments committee are nearing a decision by the High Court of Justice. Changing the composition of the committee is the centerpiece of Levin’s planned overhaul of the legal system in Israel, and he has refrained from convening it in its existing format. This morning, following the submission of arguments by both sides, the court ordered Levin to justify his failure to convene the committee. The hearing, before justices Anat Baron, David Mintz, and Yael Willner, is set for this Tuesday, September 19 at 10:00, and it will be broadcast live.

Today’s ruling means that, after receiving the arguments of both sides, the court was persuaded that the government and Levin had to justify their decision. It also means a shortening of the proceedings. In Tuesday’s hearing, the government side will speak first, since the burden of justifying its position has been transferred to it.

After today’s decision was announced, Levin asked the court to cancel it, arguing that it did not have the power to determine what should be contained in the response to the petitions. The court has referred Levin’s request to the other side for a response by 9:00 am on September 18, that is the day before the date set for hearing the petitions.

In the petitions filed by The Movement for Quality Government in Israel, the Yesh Atid Party, and a group of businesspeople, it is claimed that Levin is obliged to exercise his power to convene the judicial appointments committee, given the severe shortage of judges in Israel, and that the decision not to convene it has been made for political reasons that constitute extraneous considerations. Attorney General Gali Baharav Miara supports the petitions, and seeks to compel Levin to convene the committee.

In his response to the petitions filed yesterday evening, Levin sought to have them dismissed on the grounds that convening the committee is within his exclusive powers, and that the court has no place to intervene. He stated in the response that he was conducting "complex constitutional negotiations with the aim of forging broad agreement to resolve a public, social and political dispute, and the stance of the Attorney General is a radical one."

"Convening the judicial appointments committee is not the aim. The aim of the law is the appointment of judges. Convening the committee now, despite the deep divisions among the people and while constitutional negotiations are taking place precisely on this matter, will miss the goal and will put back the appointment of judges for a long time," Levin’s response states. He claims that the petitioners are using the petitions as a weapon to thwart the negotiations.

Leader of the Opposition Yair Lapid, who is one of the petitioners, said in response: "The decision by the High Court of Justice is a clear message by the court to the government of Israel: Israel’s citizens are more important than politics. The High Court of Justice said today what we have been saying for months: Minister of Justice Levin has taken the judicial appointments committee and the citizens of Israel hostage, and is acting contrary to his powers and contrary to the law."

Published by Globes, Israel business news - en.globes.co.il - on September 14, 2023.

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd., 2023.

Yariv Levin  credit: Alex Kolomoisky, Yedioth Aharonoth
Yariv Levin credit: Alex Kolomoisky, Yedioth Aharonoth
Israeli startup gems 2022 Globes names Finout "Most Promising Startup of 2025"

Cloud cost management solutions company Finout tops the list of Israeli startups most likely to succeed named by 80 local and foreign funds.

Mobileye CEO Amnon Shashua credit: Heinz Troll European Patent Office Mobileye posts strong Q1, reaffirms guidance despite tariffs

The Israeli advanced driving assistance systems company beat analysts' expectations on revenue and met expectations on non-GAAP net profit.

Xtend drones credit: Xtend Sentrycs teams with Xtend to strengthen drone security

The aim of the all-Israeli collaboration is to create a synergy of proven capabilities in a world where drones have become a major threat.

Intel Haifa  credit: Shutterstock Intel layoffs in Israel will benefit rivals

Industry experts agree that Intel staff dismissed in Israel will have no trouble finding work at rivals like Nvidia, as happened during last year's layoffs.

Ministry of Finance Jerusalem credit: Shutterstock Treasury sees Trump's tariffs cutting Israel's GDP growth

Amid the uncertainty that still surrounds the level of tariffs that would ultimately be imposed on Israeli goods, the annual damage to growth is estimated by the Finance Ministry at less than 0.5% of GDP.

French President Emmanuel Macron at the Paris Air Show in 2023 credit: Reuters Israel to scale down Paris Air Show presence

Due to President Emmanuel Macron's antagonism, Israel is reducing its presence at the exhibition, Ministry of Defense International Defense Cooperation Directorate (SIBAT) head Yair Kulas tells "Globes."

Jerusalem court cmplex credit: Zarhy Architects Tenders issued for two huge Jerusalem construction projects

The PFI tenders for the Gan Hotzvim tech campus and the courts complex include grants of NIS 1.7 billion for the winning bidders.

Israel Innovation Authority CEO Dror Bin Innovation Authority chief: Israel top for deep tech investment

Dror Bin told the Globes TECH IL conference that deep tech is the next wave for global tech and the rate of investment in Israel is the world's highest.

Gil Shwed and Nadav Zafrir credit: Menash Cohen With new CEO Check Point beats analysts in Q1

Revenue rose 6.5% and GAAP net profit rose 5% in Nadav Zafrir's first full quarter at the helm.

Tel Aviv light rail credit: Yossi Cohen Rishon Lezion to finance Red Line light rail extension

The Rishon Lezion Municipality will pay for part of the extension by marketing land above the planned underground depot.

Intel Haifa development center credit: Shutterstock Intel to cut 20% of workforce - report

"Bloomberg" reports that new CEO Lip-Bu Tan will announce the layoffs this week.

Healthee team credit: Healthee PR AI healthcare costs management co Healthee raises $50m

Healthee’s benefits and care navigation platform empowers employees and employers to make the most of their health benefits.

Former Shufersal CEO Itzik Abercohen credit: Eyal Izhar Competition Authority summons former Shufersal CEO to hearing

According to the indictment, Shufersal and Itzik Abercohen allegedly made public statements through which he attempted to reach arrangements to raise prices.

Reco founders Ofer Klein, Gal Nakash, and Tal Shapira credit: Elegant Photographics Israeli SaaS security co Reco raises $25m

The Tel Aviv-based company has developed a comprehensive application discovery engine capable of identifying and classifying over 50,000 applications, and providing visibility into an organization’s SaaS ecosystem.

Tel Aviv Stock Exchange credit: Tali Bogdanovsky TASE outperforms global markets in 2025

Boosted by the strong results of Israel's banks, the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange has demonstrated impressive resilience to domestic and foreign upheavals.

Metro credit: Bar Lavi Can Hyundai fill Metro vacuum created by China's exclusion?

The South Korean giant is reportedly eager to enter Israel's infrastructure sector but may not have the resources to dig the Metro tunnels.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018