Levin-Sa'ar plan makes judicial appointments a political affair

Gideon Sa'ar and Yariv Levin
Gideon Sa'ar and Yariv Levin

The proposal by two government ministers will make the selection of judges less professional and more of a political horse trade.

As the deadline set by the High Court of Justice for Minister of Justice Yariv Levin to appoint a president of the Supreme Court nears, Levin, together with Minister of Foreign Affairs Gideon Sa’ar, published a plan today that the two ministers called "a historic consensus" on changing the composition of the Judicial Selection Committee and the way it operates. The consensus, however, is between Levin and Sa’ar, two coalition ministers who are promoting a new move. The opposition is not a partner to the plan, and the Judicial Branch, with which Levin has severed working relations, heard about it from the media. According to the ministers’ announcement, the plan was drawn up after consultation with former minister of justice Yizhar Shai and General (res.) Dedy Simhi.

Political considerations will dominate

Under the proposal, which will come into force in the next Knesset, the Judicial Selection Committee will still have nine members, but the two representatives on it of the Israel Bar Association, which campaigned against Levin’s judicial overhaul, will be replaced. In their stead, there will be one lawyer chosen by the coalition and one chosen by the opposition, which means that although these are meant to be legal professionals they will become appointees of the politicians on both sides.

The proposal also changes the balance of forces on the committee, reducing the power of the judges and elevating the power of the politicians. The appointment of a judge to the Supreme Court will require a majority of only five of the nine committee members (instead of the current seven), but support for it will be required from one coalition representative and one opposition representative. The upshot will be that political considerations will dictate the selection.

Each side can rule out candidates. This requirement can be expected to lead to paralysis, as has already happened over the past two years, since the retirement of Supreme Court justices Esther Hayut and Anat Baron, and recently Uzi Vogelman as well. The committee does not appoint judges to the Supreme Court unless there is agreement by a majority of seven members, and so the Supreme Court has been short of three judges.

To resolve this, Levin and Sa’ar propose "a mechanism for overcoming paralysis in the selection of judges." This mechanism is a mechanism for appointing judges favored by politicians. Under it, if a year goes by without an appointment, and two judges are lacking, the representatives of the coalition and the opposition can propose three candidates each, from which the other side will choose one. The coalition will thus be able to introduce its candidate onto the Supreme Court, at the price of a candidate favored by the opposition. In lower courts too, for which judges are currently appointed by an ordinary majority of five out of the nine committee members, there will need to be broad agreement: under the plan, the majority will have to contain at least one coalition representative, one opposition representative, and one judge.

Alongside these changes, Levin and Sa’ar agreed on dramatic change in the shape of a Basic Law: Legislation, which will take time to enact, as no draft bill has been formulated on the matter, but the proposal contains a dangerous change, in that it includes abolition of judicial review of basic laws other than basic laws that infringe the principle of equality in elections, and even those can be struck down only by a majority of three-quarters of the Supreme Court judges. Even ordinary laws, such as might infringe human rights, will be able to be struck down only by a majority of the Supreme Court judges.

This means, among other things, that the reasonability test for executive decisions could be abolished, rendering the Supreme Court (sitting as the High Court of Justice) unable to intervene in unreasonable government decision and corrupt appointments. The High Court of Justice has already struck down a law sponsored by the current government that sought to abolish the test. The government will be able to promote extreme legislation, and it will not be possible to cancel it. Levin and Sa’ar are trying to soften the blow by proposing that basic laws will be passed, amended, or repealed by different procedures from those for ordinary legislation, but that will not prevent the governing coalition from passing laws that are liable to harm democracy, and the Supreme Court’s hands will be tied.

Published by Globes, Israel business news - en.globes.co.il - on January 9, 2025.

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd., 2025.

Gideon Sa'ar and Yariv Levin
Gideon Sa'ar and Yariv Levin
Itay Raved  credit: Jonathan Bloom From a rooftop in India to running Tesla Israel

Itay Raved's career drifted from law to media consulting to acting, before he finally found his niche.

Dr. Adi Tzoref-Lorenz credit: Jonathan Bloom "My research says I don't accept there is no answer"

The death of a cancer patient spurred Dr. Adi Zoref-Lorenz into developing the OHI index, which allows the diagnosis of the HLH side effect from cancer immunotherapy, based on two blood tests.

Dr. R  credit: Jonathan Bloom Wounded in his tank, now R develops protection systems

"I was close to death, but it sharpened my awareness of the products we develop for the IDF."

Ella Kenan  credit: Yossi Cohen A fighter of fake news about Israel

Ella Kenan saw online denial of October 7 happening straightaway. "I realized we had 24 hours, or we were doomed"

Liron Horshi credit: Jonathan Bloom Wiz's talent manager nurtures $1b workforce

Wiz's $32 billion sale to Google was rooted in the cloud security product if offers but could not have been achieved without the quality of its employees built by human resources chief Liron Horshi.

Yoav Shoham  credit: Eyal Izhar Yoav Shoham: AI isn't too smart, it's too dumb

AI21 Labs founder and CEO Prof. Yoav Shoham talks to "Globes" about dubious doomsday predictions, what should really concern us, and what could make Israel a global AI leader.

Record public company profits  credit: Tali Bogdanovsky Profits peak, but reckoning awaits

In what may seem a paradox, profits grew in almost every sector on the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange last year, but the boom was largely fueled by government spending.

Insightec COO and general manager Eyal Zadicario credit: Ness Productions After 25 years of losses Insightec focuses on profit

Insightec COO and general manager Eyal Zadicario tells "Globes" about himself and the Israeli ultrasound company's long battle to change the medical world.

Amit Shaked credit: Tomer Lesher Driven to succeed but balancing ambition with wellbeing

At just 14, cybersecurity company Rubrik VP Amit Shaked began a B.Sc. in Computer Science and Math and mapped out his entire future, which included IDF service in the 8200 unit, and an inevitable huge startup exit.

Advs. Roy Keidar and Netanella Treistman credit: Nicky Westphal AI blind spot startups can no longer afford to ignore

How AI governance can assist startups and enhance their ability to succeed.

Dr. Ola Gutzeit  credit: Ketty Hakim The doctor breaking new ground in fertility

"We know nothing about the female reproductive system," says Dr. Ola Gutzeit of Rambam Hospital. She seeks to change that, and hence change IVF for the better.

Google CEO Sundar Pichai  crediit: Shutterstock Why Google is paying so much for Wiz

Lagging its competitors in cloud and AI, and facing challenges to its core advertising business, Google could be looking to spend its way out of trouble.

Donald Trump speaking on the deck of the USS Gerald R. Ford  at its launch in 2017 credit: Reuters/Jonathan Ernst Houthis between hammer and anvil

President Trump appears determined to end the Houthi threat to shipping, while Iran has abandoned the last active arm of its "axis of resistance."

Prof. Douglas Irwin  credit: Inbal Marmari "We will all be poorer"

Prof. Douglas Irwin, an expert on international trade, talks to "Globes" about the impact of President Trump's tariffs policy, and what Israel can do about it.

Rooftop solar panels credit: Shutterstock Does it pay for homes to install rooftop solar panels?

As the Israeli government steps up efforts to encourage homeowners to produce their own electricity from rooftop panels, "Globes" investigates the advantages and pitfalls.

Dop Elbit banner at London's Allianz HQ credit: Reuters PA Images Violence against Israeli defense cos in UK escalates

"The Sunday Times" has investigated Palestine Action, a radical left-wing group that targets Israeli defense companies, their subsidiaries, and corporations and banks with any connection to Israel.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018