Comptroller: Trains - too few carriages and tracks

Israel Railways
Israel Railways

The number of railway passengers rose by 80% in 2007-2010.

At the beginning of the decade, Israel Railways appeared to be a ray of light in the state of transportation in Israel. Railways were in demand, and attracted passengers who did not usually use public transportation. With the development of routes and the opening of stations, the number railway passengers rose by 80% in 2007-2010. The State Comptroller's report, however, shows that Israel Railways was simply unprepared to this demand. The forecasts that it sent to the Ministry of Transport and the Ministry of Finance predicted 25% less railway passenger traffic than the actual numbers.

As a result of a lack of planning, Israel Railways was late in ordering carriages, and the Ministry of Transport and the Ministry of Finance approved only some of those orders. Israel Railways reported an urgent need for 168 carriages in 2013, but only 141 were approved, and only 60 of those are in use. The urgent need of carriages resulted in an order without a tender from Bombardier, Israel Railways' main carriages supplier, based on old tenders from the beginning of the preceding decade. The delay in ordering carriages means that when the high-speed route to Jerusalem goes into full operation in 2021, its occupancy rate at peak hours will be 120%.

Railway tracks are also lacking. As of now, the only way to improve passenger service is to turn direct routes into local routes, which makes the journey take longer. For example, trains from Beer Sheva to Tel Aviv are also stopping at Holon stations, thereby wasting the time of passengers from Beer Sheva previously served by the direct train. In the future, the limited capacity of the Ayalon artery will make it impossible to expand service on many routes. Both the installation of a new signals system, and even a new division of signals segments, which makes it possible to better utilize the existing tracks, are being delayed, mainly due to Israel Railways' management problems. The State Comptroller cites the prolonged delays in adding a fourth track on the crowded Ayalon artery, which currently makes it impossible to increase the frequency of trains.

The great congestion on the trains and tracks is increasing the likelihood of delays and creating a problem of trains being canceled. The number canceled trains soared 473% to 10,441 in 2015-2017. The State Comptroller notes the growing congestion in railway stations and the lack of preparation for it. It is taking passengers longer to get on and off trains because of the congestion on the railway platforms, causing delays in the trains leaving the stations.

Getting to the stations is not easy. Despite various efforts at coordination between Israel Railways and the bus transportation operators, there is no efficient bus service to many railway stations, and bus times are often not synchronized with train schedules. Most railway stations have a severe shortage of parking spaces for cars, which leads drivers to park in forbidden and dangerous places.

The Ministry of Transport said in response, "The ministry has been leading an unprecedented revolution for a decade by building a nationwide network of railway tracks reaching all over Israel. It has increased the number of railway passengers threefold or more. A number of years ago, the minister of transport led the biggest reform ever in a government company in Israel at Israel Railways. The company now requires further reorganization, which Israel Railways' board of directors is leading. The fourth track along the Ayalon Highway is a very difficult project that Minister of Transport Yisrael Katz began, after many years of stagnation. Its planning is proceeding rapidly."

Published by Globes, Israel business news - en.globes.co.il - on March 13, 2019

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2019

Israel Railways
Israel Railways
Fencing goes up Petah Tikva's Segula neighborhood  credit: NTA The Metro is really happening

Although there are skeptics who doubt that the project will ever be realized, there are now enough signs on the ground to indicate that they are probably wrong.

Ben Gurion airport Terminal 1 credit: Shutterstock Ben Gurion airport's Terminal 1 reopens

Terminal 1 at Ben Gurion airport reopened yesterday to domestic flights, while international flights will start using the terminal from Sunday, March 30.

Minister of Interior Moshe Arbel credit: Cadya Levy Interior Minister: There is no deep state in Israel

Minister of Interior Moshe Arbel told the Globes Services conference that civil servants are dedicated employees who serve the public.

Minimum wage credit: Tali Bogdanovsky Minimum wage in Israel to rise next week

The monthly minimum wage in Israel will be revised upwards by 6%.

Bank of Israel  credit: Shutterstock/Alon Adika Bank of Israel slams gov't fiscal policy

Governor Prof. Amir Yaron wrote in the annual report that the government's measures are not enough to ensure a sustained decline in debt-to-GDP ratio.

Minister of Justice Yariv Levin credit: Noam Moskovitz Knesset Spokesperson Knesset passes Judicial Selection Law

The new law makes judicial appointments subject to political control.

Airbnb credit: Reuters Knesset ignores Airbnb tax evasion loophole

The Israel Hotels Association has slammed the government's indifference to tax evasion by Airbnb landlords, which it insists promotes unfair competition.

GMT CFO Eran Tibon credit: PR Political tensions tempt Israelis to move funds abroad

According to data from advanced financial services company Global Money Transfer, steps taken by the Israeli cabinet to oust Shin Bet chief Ronen Bar, and Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara, could cause capital to flee Israel.

Sde Dov credit: Guy Yehieli Tenders close for 2,744 more homes in Sde Dov

Four tenders closed last month for the north Tel Aviv district saw a decrease of about 40% in the prices of land, and there is great interest in the prices these latest tenders will fetch.

Rafael CEO Yoav Turgeman credit: Rafael Spokesperson Rafael CEO: Iron Beam will be ready in 2025 as promised

In presenting record financial results for 2024, Yoav Turgeman tells "Globes" that the high energy laser weapon system will be operational this year.

Tel Aviv credit: Shutterstock Rent rises moderate due to emigration and reserve duty

Rents only rose 4% in 2024, the Bank of Israel reports, despite the large number of evacuees, due to the negative migration balance and the large number of young people in the army reserves.

Moody's, Benjamin Netanyahu, Bezalel Smotrich, credit: Shutter stock, Government Spokesperson, Tali Bogdanovsky Moody's: Political risks weigh on Israel's rating

"Israel's sovereign credit profile reflects very high political risks that have weakened economic and fiscal strength."

Stef Wertheimer  credit: Reuters Industrialist and philanthropist Stef Wertheimer dies aged 98

Wertheimer founded Iscar, which was sold to Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway, and was behind many industrial and social initiatives, as well as having a brief political career.

Island founders Dan Amiga and Mike Fey credit: Antonio Delucci Browser security co Island raises $250m at $5b valuation

The company has developed a communications technology that enables fast remote connection to corporate computers.

Yossi and Shlomi Amir  credit: Jonathan Bloom Shufersal doubles annual profit

Streamlining measures by brothers Yossi and Shlomi Amir since they took control have vastly improved the supermarket chains profitability metrics.

Africa Israel Residence CEO Ronit Eshed Levy credit: Cadya Levy "Jewish communities want to move together to Jerusalem"

Africa Israel Residence CEO Ronit Eshed Levy told the Globes Going Long on Israel investment conference about urban renewal in Jerusalem.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018