Defense budget cuts create difficult dilemma

Comment

The Defense Ministry wants the government to decide what to cut and by how much.

At the Kirya in Tel Aviv, Ministry of Defense officials are no longer willing to take sole responsibility for the planned cut in the defense budget, and are telling the government that if it wants to billions from the defense budget then it should decide what to cut and by how much. The ministry's officials, faced with regional upheaval, growing threats, complex challenges, and the needs of the IDF and intelligence services, refuse to decide alone whether to stop production of the Merkava tank and the Iron Dome anti-missile system, slow procurement of new Leopard APCs, or postpone deployment of an effective cyber warfare system.

Each of these programs costs billions of shekels, and the Ministry of Defense officials want the entire government to make the decision; for each and every minister to sign on the dotted line for which shekel will be saved and bear the responsibility of the consequences, and even appear before the investigative committee to explain why and on what basis he thought it was possible to forego this program.

This is why the Ministry of Defense and the IDF are adamantly refusing to detail how the multibillion shekel cut in the defense budget will be made. They have already done their work, warned about the next war and the need to procure the means to fight it, stated that the Egypt of today is not the Egypt of ousted President Hosni Mubarak.

The Ministry of Finance and Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee are unimpressed by the outcry, calling it fear-mongering that no longer works on anyone. They say that the solutions are in the fat: stick with the Brodet committee structure for defense spending and reductions personnel, elimination of overseas defense delegations, and cutting current costs. The Ministry of Finance says that these measures, taken together, are enough to supply the government's budget shortfall.

Weeks ago, Minister of Defense Ehud Barak set up a special committee chaired by Ministry of Defense director general Udi Shani to review the defense budget with a fine-toothed comb, in Barak's own words. The team has marked every project, priced each one separately, listed what each component is used for, the characterizations of each missile, radar system, and development, but refuses to doom even one of them. The detailed document will be sent to every cabinet minister for them to decide.

When top defense officials declared in recent weeks that all options were on the table, they did not mean just to elegantly evade possible questions by an investigative about Iran, they were referring to every project already perceived as a national project: shutting down the Merkava Mark IV production line and slowing the transfer of IDF bases to the Negev, which will cost many billions of shekels now and in the future. Meanwhile, Bedouin will continue to take over land designated for the new bases. It has already happened near Omer, where the IDF's new intelligence HQ is slated to be sited.

100 civilian companies from Kiryat Shmona to Beersheva are involved in the Merkava tank program, ranging from large factories to small workshops that manufacture components for the tank, would close down if the Ministry of Defense stops placing orders. In recent weeks, many manufacturers have spoken about the crippling atmosphere of uncertainty. The Ministry of Defense knows this, and behind closed doors, tries to use this as leverage to warn about the loss of hundreds of jobs, main in the periphery.

If Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad no longer moves the Israeli government, maybe the prospect of a mass of unemployed men hitting the Employment Service's gates will.

Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes-online.com - on November 29, 2011

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2011

Yoav Karny  illustration: Gil Gibli Israel must defeat its foes, and understand its critics

Israelis are hardly aware of the breach that pictures from Gaza cause in the hearts of people once well-disposed towards them.

Yoav Karny  illustration: Gil Gibli Will everyone get the hints?

Israel has effectively warned Iran to cease and desist, but it needs to understand the signals from the US as well.

Yoav Karny  illustration: Gil Gibli US aid with a sting

A new military aid package reaffirms Israel's special relationship with the US; penalizing an IDF unit for human rights violations signals a change of tone.

Benjamin Netanyahu and Bezalel Smotrich credit: Ronen Zvulun Reuters Israel regressing to an underdeveloped country

The economy will quickly rebound from negative growth but in the longer term, unless the government wakes up and changes policies, the country's prospects are bleak.

Yoav Karny  illustration: Gil Gibli The obsession that led to war with Hamas

The concept that Islamism is preferable to Arab nationalism has guided Israeli policy for decades, and brought upon us the disaster of October 7.

Yoav Karny  illustration: Gil Gibli Loyal Joe

It will have surprised many Israelis to find out how deep US President Joe Biden's feelings for Israel run.

Yoav Karny  illustration: Gil Gibli The global significance of a hole in a fence

Hamas's murderous infiltration into Israel ties in with a larger effort to destroy the US-led world order.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Bank of Israel admits failure to tame inflation

In the announcement on its latest interest rate hike, the Bank of Israel acknowledges that it does not have the ability to control inflation.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli A political Chief Statistician? Too scary to think about

Netanyahu's attempt to appoint a crony to head the Central Bureau of Statistics threatens to sap confidence in the economy.

Yoav Karny  illustration: Gil Gibli Iran and Saudi Arabia upend Israel's defense strategy

The Chinese-sponsored reconciliation between Saudi Arabia and Iran, and Iran's growing military ties with Russia, cast a long shadow over Israel.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Senseless

When even common courtesy is condemned by political partisans, we are seeing the real threat to Israel's future.

David Gillis  illustration: Gil Gibli The truth about reasonableness

US commentators are welcome to contribute to Israel's judicial reform debate, but they should be wary about their sources.

Benjamin Netanyahu and government ministers in the Knesset  credit: Yossi Zamir Gov't endangering Israel's economy? What are the signs?

Doomsayers see political events in Israel undermining investor confidence. "Globes" surveys some indicators that will give early warning.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Stop shouting, start talking

The new government's actions and proposals are not ideal, but not the apocalypse either, and reasoned discourse should produce acceptable solutions.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Forecasting is for fools

The market has already priced in the expected and nobody foresees the unexpected, which is maybe why economists so often get their predictions badly wrong.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli 2023 could be a tough diplomatic year for Israel

The war in Ukraine and growing unrest in Iran pose challenges for Israel but the biggest problem will be if Netanyahu is unable to restrain his right-wing coalition partners.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018