Court rules state must conscript yeshiva students to IDF

High Court of Justice hearing on conscription  credit: Amit Shabi, Yedioth Ahronoth
High Court of Justice hearing on conscription credit: Amit Shabi, Yedioth Ahronoth

The High Court of Justice ruled that the government was violating the principle of equality before the law, and that state support for yeshivas whose students unlawfully avoid conscription must cease.

Israel’s Supreme Court, sitting as the High Court of Justice, ruled unanimously today that the state must act to draft yeshiva students, and that it was not possible to continue state financial support to yeshivas for students who had not received an exemption from military service.

The panel of nine justices found that at present there was no legal framework allowing a distinction to be made between yeshiva students and others due for military service. Accordingly, the state has no power to order sweeping avoidance of conscription, and must act in accordance with the Defense Service Law.

The 42-page ruling was written by acting president of the Supreme Court Judge Uzi Vogelman, with the concurrence of the other eight justices: Yitzhak Amit, Noam Sohlberg, Daphne Barak-Erez, David Mintz, Yael Willner, Alex Stein, Ofer Grosskopf, and Gila Canfy-Steinitz.

The judges ruled that the government’s decision allowing haredim (ultra-Orthodox Jews) who declare that their Torah study is their vocation not to be conscripted, after the law (the so-called Tal Law) regularizing this had been repealed, was flawed "since the government thereby instructed the military authorities to apply illegitimate selective enforcement."

The ruling states that the distinction between yeshiva students and others liable for military service has no anchor in law, and that in seeking to distinguish between the two groups in enforcing the law "the government severely harmed the rule of law and the principle that all individuals are equal before the law."

The judges rejected the government’s claim that the military authorities had discretion as to which groups in the population to conscript. This, the judgment states, "undermines the very existence of the duty to be conscripted that applies equally to the citizens of the state, and also contradicts the duty of the administrative authority to exercise its discretion in an egalitarian fashion."

The judgement states that the government has been acting unlawfully, and that "the difficulty in this state of affairs has become sharper in view of the continuing war in which the State of Israel finds itself, with its consequences for the army’s need for manpower to fulfil its vital tasks… The current stance of the defense establishment is that there is a concrete and urgent need for additional manpower."

The judges pointed out that, in 1949, when exemptions were first granted from military service on the grounds of Torah study as a vocation, the number of yeshiva students thereby exempted was just 400, and that over the years the number had grown to a completely different order of size. According to the figures presented by the state, at the end of June 2023 the number stood at some 63,000.

The court found that, as a result of the conclusion that there was no normative framework for exempting yeshiva students from conscription, it was not possible to continue transferring financial support to yeshivas and kolels (institutes of higher rabbinic studies) for students who had not received a lawful exemption or whose service had not been lawfully deferred.

On the issue of separate legal representation for different government ministries and agencies, the judges reaffirmed that, in the absence of a court ruling on the matter in question, the Attorney General’s interpretation of the law was binding on the executive arm.

The petitioners calling for the end of discrimination in conscription were The Movement for Quality Government in Israel, the Brothers in Arms movement, and 240 mothers of both male and female combat soldiers. At the same time, petitions by the Ayalon Social Rights Forum and the Civil Democracy Movement were heard focusing on ending state support for Torah institutions whose students avoided conscription. Both groups argued that there was no legal basis for not conscripting yeshiva students.

In order to try to block intervention by the High Court of Justice, the government is currently promoting a bill allowing most yeshiva students to be exempted from military service. The bill is under discussion in the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee before second and third readings. In the High Court hearing, the court made clear that there was no room to wait for further legislation after it had already waited six years, and after the issue had not been resolved in the past twenty-five years.

Published by Globes, Israel business news - en.globes.co.il - on June 25, 2024.

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd., 2024.

High Court of Justice hearing on conscription  credit: Amit Shabi, Yedioth Ahronoth
High Court of Justice hearing on conscription credit: Amit Shabi, Yedioth Ahronoth
El Al plane credit: Shutterstock El Al receives state approval to distribute dividend

The Israeli airline has now announced that it will be able to distribute up to 30% of net profit in 2025 and up to 40% in 2026-2028.

Relocation credit: Michal Raz-Haimovitz How to turn the tech relocation tide

With thousands of tech employees leaving Israel, the Innovation Authority proposes measures that could reverse the trend.

groundcover founders credit: Yossi Yarom Israeli observability co groundcover raises $35m

groundcover has developed a “Bring Your Own Cloud” (BYOC) observability solution, redefining the architecture of a modern observability platform.

Tel Aviv Stock Exchange credit: Shutterstock MagioreStock Foreign investment in TASE hits five-year high

Foreign investors have been flocking to the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange in recent weeks, the TASE research department tells "Globes."

Elbit Systems tank turret systems credit: Elbit Systems Elbit Systems wins $100m tank turret systems deal

The Israel defense electronics company will supply its advanced UT30 MK2 unmanned turret systems to General Dynamics European Land Systems (GDELS) to be supplied to a NATO European country.

Tomer Weingarten Photo: PR Trump targets SentinelOne exec in act of revenge

The US administration has suspended the security clearance of the company's chef intelligence and public policy officer Chris Krebs and everyone associated with him.

Tel Aviv Stock Exchange share prices rising credit: Tali Bogdanovsky TASE opens sharply higher after Trump U-turn on tariffs

The pause is being interpreted as a climb down after US President Donald Trump admitted he had made the move to calm the markets.

Ashot Ashkelon credit: Ministry of Defense Up 250%, Ashot Ashkelon wins another Defense Ministry order

The Israeli defense company's share price has risen 250% in the past three years since FIMI Opportunity Funds acquired control.

Liad Agmon credit: Eyal Izhar Insight Partners Liad Agmon steps down as managing partner

Serial entrepreneur Agmon has served as a partner at Insight Partners Israel alongside Daniel Aronovitz who set up the Israel office.

Shekels credit: Shutterstock Vladerina32 Shekel slide resumes amid escalating tariff war

The Bank of Israel is not expected to intervene in the forex market despite the sharp depreciation of the shekel.

Nir Zuk credit: Inbal Marmari Palo Alto Networks mulls buying AI security co for $700m

Sources inform "Globes" that on Palo Alto's radar is Protect AI.

President Donald Trump hosts Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu credit: Reuters Kevin Mohatt Israeli officials confident on US tariff concessions

Senior Israeli figures believe that concessions could be tied to progress on strategic regional political issues that are important to President Trump.

Phoenix Investment House CEO Avner Hadad  credit: Tommy Harpaz "The market has priced in all the bad things"

Phoenix Investment House CEO Avner Hadad says US markets could continue to fall, but that we are close to interesting territory for patient investors.

Tel Aviv credit: Shutterstock Tel Aviv slips in World's Wealthiest Cities ranking

Tel Aviv's position as one of the world's wealthiest cities took a big knock over the past year as it slipped from 42nd to 48th in investment advisors Henley & Co.'s "World's Wealthiest Cities" Top 50 ranking.

Leviathan platform  credit: Albatross C'ttee seen recommending no cut in gas exports

The Dayan committee on the future of the gas sector estimates that Israel's natural gas reserves will run out in 2045.

Accountant General Yali Rothenberg credit: Rafi Kutz Israel's fiscal deficit continues to narrow

The deficit narrowed in the twelve months to the end of March 2025, for the sixth consecutive month, Ministry of Finance accountant general Yali Rothenberg reported today.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018