Millions squandered on unrealistic projects

Israel Railways Photo: Shutterstock ASAP Creative
Israel Railways Photo: Shutterstock ASAP Creative

Israel's government has spent NIS 120 million planning railways to Eilat and Kiryat Shmona - projects that have been frozen indefinitely.

Last week's opening of Ramon Airport in Timna near Eilat is an excellent opportunity to ask what happened to the vision of a high-speed railway line between Tel Aviv and Eilat.

In the previous government, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Minister of Transport Yisrael Katz obtained cabinet approval for a railway to shorten travel time between Eilat and Tel Aviv to two hours. Netanyahu imagined a Japanese-style bullet train flying through the Arava on the way to Eilat at 250 kilometers an hour.

The Ministry of Finance warned Netanyahu that this toy would cost NIS 50 billion. "When it gets to NIS 100 billion, let me know," Netanyahu responded.

Only one transportation project competed with the enthusiasm of Netanyahu and Katz for building a railway to Eilat: a high-speed railway from Karmiel to Kiryat Shmona with 60 kilometers of track, including 22 kilometers in tunnels under Mount Meron. This package was to cost "only" NIS 10 billion, a bargain in comparison with the Eilat Railway.

The escalating problem of congestion in metropolitan Tel Aviv made Netanyahu and Katz realize that there were more urgent transportation projects than bullet trains to Eilat and Kiryat Shmona. The two projects were put in the deep freeze, but not before quite a bit of money was spent on planning them.

A probe by the Ministry of Finance revealed that planning for the high-speed route to Eilat has cost NIS 70 million to date, while NIS 50 million more allocated to the project has not yet been used. NIS 50 million has been spent on the railway to Kiryat Shmona. NIS 120 million was spent on planning projects that were unnecessary and will not happen in the next decade. If they are ever carried out, they will have to be planned again in any case, because the circumstances would have changed. This money could have been used for adding to the National List of Reimbursed Drugs, improving safety in the workplace, and innumerable better purposes.

Published by Globes, Israel business news - en.globes.co.il - on January 28, 2019

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2019

Israel Railways Photo: Shutterstock ASAP Creative
Israel Railways Photo: Shutterstock ASAP Creative
Atlas Invest founders Globes readers choose Atlas Invest as favorite 2025 startup

The Tel Aviv-based startup has developed a digital platform allowing US real estate developers to raise capital and loans from investors.

Egged bus  credit: Shlomi Yosef Public transport fare reform won't improve public transport

From Friday fares will rise, while exemptions and discounts will be expanded, but what persuades people to switch to public transport is reliability, convenience and speed.

Ella-Tamar Adhanan credit: Rodolphe Felix Israel's go-to tech banker in the US

As head of SVB's Israel Market, and director of US Business Development for Technology Banking & Investor Coverage, Ethiopian-Israeli Ella-Tamar Adhanan has helped restore confidence in the bank.

Commuter jam credit: Eyal Izhar Israeli commuters impose 45 minute limit

Data show that employees would rather change jobs than travel longer, so companies with fast public transport access find it easiest to hire.

Nochi Danner credit: Tamar Matsafi Nochi Dankner reinvented

Still mired in debt, a court case sheds light on the new life of the former 'golden boy' of Israeli business, since his release from prison.

Relocation credit: Michal Raz-Haimovitz How to turn the tech relocation tide

With thousands of tech employees leaving Israel, the Innovation Authority proposes measures that could reverse the trend.

Gal Rosenblum credit: Jonathan Bloom Israel's Adidas franchise chief boosted 2024 sales 40%

Gal Rosenblum talks about his perfect job, which combines his love of sport, fashion and data analysis.

Michael Rogers  credit: Team8 The spy who came into Israeli tech

Former US National Security Agency head Michael Rogers is now a partner at VC fund Team8. He talks to "Globes" about intelligence, geopolitics, and what amazes him about Israel's tech industry.

Dr. Neal Tsur credit: Yossi Zamir "Trump was just an excuse for market drop"

Dr. Neal Tsur studies what makes complex systems like stock markets ripe for change, and he has put his money where his theory is.

Roy Goldenberg  credit: Jonathan Bloom Making a better world for the disabled

Personal experience motivated Roy Goldenberg to become Israel director of TOM Tikkun Olam Makers. "TOM will be one of the biggest organizations to come out of Israel," he says.

Itay Raved  credit: Jonathan Bloom From a rooftop in India to running Tesla Israel

Itay Raved's career drifted from law to media consulting to acting, before he finally found his niche.

Dr. Adi Tzoref-Lorenz credit: Jonathan Bloom "My research says I don't accept there is no answer"

The death of a cancer patient spurred Dr. Adi Zoref-Lorenz into developing the OHI index, which allows the diagnosis of the HLH side effect from cancer immunotherapy, based on two blood tests.

Dr. R  credit: Jonathan Bloom Wounded in his tank, now R develops protection systems

"I was close to death, but it sharpened my awareness of the products we develop for the IDF."

Ella Kenan  credit: Yossi Cohen A fighter of fake news about Israel

Ella Kenan saw online denial of October 7 happening straightaway. "I realized we had 24 hours, or we were doomed"

Liron Horshi credit: Jonathan Bloom Wiz's talent manager nurtures $1b workforce

Wiz's $32 billion sale to Google was rooted in the cloud security product if offers but could not have been achieved without the quality of its employees built by human resources chief Liron Horshi.

Yoav Shoham  credit: Eyal Izhar Yoav Shoham: AI isn't too smart, it's too dumb

AI21 Labs founder and CEO Prof. Yoav Shoham talks to "Globes" about dubious doomsday predictions, what should really concern us, and what could make Israel a global AI leader.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018