Critics slam draft national AI plan

Isaac Ben-Israel
Isaac Ben-Israel

"There is no need for another government body to coordinate AI matters."

Members of the Council for Higher Education Planning and Budget Committee, together with the Israel Innovation Authority and the Ministry of Finance Budget Department, are opposing some of the recommendations in the draft report by the committee for assessing progress in artificial intelligence (AI) reported early last week in "Globes."

Planning and Budget Committee chair Prof. Yaffa Zilbershats, Innovation Authority chairman Dr. Ami Appelbaum, and Ministry of Finance deputy budget director Asaf Wassercug wrote a letter to assessment committee heads Maj. Gen. (res.) Prof. Isaac Ben-Israel and Prof. Eviatar Matania setting forth their objections to several of the published recommendations. The three letter writers objected to both the recommendations themselves and the way decisions were made.

"We wish to draw your attention to the fact that as members of the steering committee for the national enterprise for safe intelligence systems (AI, U.B.), which you head, we were amazed to find out about the committee's recommendation through the media, before the draft report was sent to us, as per normal procedure, and before a comprehensive discussion of the recommendations was held by the steering committee meant to discuss those recommendations," the letter stated.

The steering committee is one of 15 subcommittees set up in October to discuss the needs and best policy concerning the various aspects of promoting AI, such as professional training, ethical use of the technology, computer infrastructure, national projects, etc. The purpose of the steering committee is to coordinate the various work committees' conclusions for submitting for government approval.

The letter of opposition argues against both the formation of the committee itself and against one of its conclusions - establishing an integration committee to coordinate the handling of the matter with all of the relevant parties, and which will operate under the auspices of the Prime Minister's Office. This model is the same as that of the National Cyber Bureau, which resulted from recommendations by similar committees early in the decade, following which the National Cyber Directorate was founded in the Prime Minister's Office.

"The basic question about the initiative - why government intervention of the proposed type is needed - has not yet been clarified and answered," the letter says. "This industry is booming in the private sector in Israel, and is attracting large resources to it at this time, including private investment, excellent personnel, inputs from international companies, etc. For example, there are already more than 2,000 startups in the field, and the projected total investment in these companies in 2019 is over $1 billion, and is continually increasing. The relevant government ministries responsible for promoting such matters are acting in a number of channels at this time, including the allocation of government budgets, in both the civilian and defense spheres."

Talking to "Globes," the plan's opponents criticized the idea of setting up such an integrative body. They explained, "The conclusion that an agency should be established to integrate all of the work of the various ministries is a great error. We already have an agency working on the matter, called The National Infrastructure Forum for Research and Development (TELEM), in which various government agencies work together, and it has already proven its ability to handle such matters, as it did in the promotion of quantum technologies."

The letter referred to the fact that the committee for promoting quantum technologies, headed by former Chief Scientist Orna Berry, has also completed its work, and is waiting for approval of its conclusions. The volume of government investment sought in quantum technologies is very modest in comparison with the amounts being requested for promotion of AI.

"The committee has representatives of higher education institutions; the Ministry of Defense; the Ministry of Finance; the Ministry of Science, Technology, and Space; the Council for Higher Education Planning and Budget Committee; and Digital Israel. There is no need to establish another body to coordinate AI, as in cyber, and there was also no need for it in cyber. The agencies are perfectly capable of working together; there is no need for a body that will only get into conflicts with the government agencies," the letter states.

The critics especially attacked the recommendation to focus on agriculture. They wrote, "We think that the state should step in where there is market failure, and the existing market failure is a shortage of personnel. The state should invest in opening government databases that will be accessible for AI research, and then matters such as shortening waiting lines, agriculture, and others will be solved in any case."

Ben-Israel said in response, "The report is a draft, and discussion of it has not ended. We will finish the work we started."

Published by Globes, Israel business news - en.globes.co.il - on November 24, 2019

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2019

Isaac Ben-Israel
Isaac Ben-Israel
Inflation  credit: Tali Bogdanovsky Unexpectedly low February CPI reading cuts inflation

While inflation in Israel in the 12 months to the end of February 2025 is lower than forecast, housing prices continue to rise.

Yitzhak Tshuva credit: Gidon Levy and Tali Bogdanovsky Competition Authority allows Delek takeover of Isracard

The Competition Authority is considered the easier of the two regulatory hurdles that the deal must overcome, the other being the Supervisor of Banks.

David Amsalem  credit  Noam Moskowitz, Knesset Spokesperson's Office Rafael to pay state NIS 444m dividend

The minister in charge of the Government Companies Authority, David Amsalem, has approved the payment by the defense company.

Barak MX air defense system  credit: IAI IAI profit jumps 55%

Israel Aerospace Industries posted a net profit of $493 million for 2024, and ended the year with an all-time high orders backlog of $25 billion.

A TSG system in tactical use  credit: PR TSG signs cooperation agreement with US defense co

The agreement includes the integration of TSG's advanced technologies into sensor-based defense systems, which will be integrated into the operational systems of US defense units.

Bria CEO Yair Adato credit: Kseniia Poliak Israeli visual generative AI co Bria raises $40m

Bria’s Visual Generative AI platform empowers businesses to create predictable, controllable, and on-brand content that aligns with their visual language.

Amnon Shashua and Aviram Ziv credit: Eyal Izhar OrCam stymied by investor dispute with Shashua

Demands by institutional investors are blocking the visual and hearing impairment device developer's recovery plan.

Work on the Green Line credit: Bar Lavi Egged wins tender to operate TA light rail Purple, Green Lines

NTA awarded the tender to Egged, which already operates the Red Line, despite government ministry opposition to one operator for the entire network.

Gabi Seroussi illustration: Gil Gibli Board chooses Seroussi as IAI chair as Erdan freezes candidacy

Israel Aerospace Industries board chose Gabi Seroussi as chair even though he did not to go through the preliminary process of the Government Companies Authority appointments review committee.

Bavli Park penthouse credit: Eyal Tagar Tel Aviv Park Bavli penthouse sells for NIS 43m

A 44th floor penthouse in one of the two towers in businessman Yitzhak Tshuva's Park Bavli project has been bought by an Israeli businessperson.

El Al aircraft  credit: Yoav Yaari El Al pilots receive nearly NIS 250,000 bonus each

Thanks to the agreements signed with the unions in 2018, El Al's employees as well as senior management share in last year's success.

Pentera CEO Amitai Ratzon credit: Eyal Izhar Israeli security validation co Pentera raises $60m

Pentera's platform enables security teams to analyze complete attack paths, identify root causes, and prioritize remediation for effective risk reduction.

Tel Aviv credit: Shutterstock Supply of unsold new homes hits record

Israel's real estate market is sliding into recession with 78,000 unsold new apartments in January, the Central Bureau of Statistics reports.

D&B chairman Doron Cohen and Meitar partner Dan Geva Meitar reclaims title of Israel's biggest law firm

Meitar has first place with 537 lawyers, followed by Herzog Fox Neeman with 512 lawyers, according to the latest Dun's 100 rankings.

First International Bank of Israel CEO Eli Cohen  credit: Eyal Toueg First Int'l posts top return on equity

First International Bank of Israel's return on equity in 2024 was 19%, the highest among Israel's banks.

Dina Ben Tal Ganancia  credit: Guy Kushi & Yariv Fein El Al almost quintuples profit

The airline posted a net profit of $545 million for 2024, 4.7 times the profit in 2023, and an all-time high.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018