Egypt compensation ruling jeopardizes gas exports

Leviathan
Leviathan

Market experts discuss the ramifications of the arbitration ruling that Egypt must pay Israel Electric Corp $1.8 billion.

“Egypt does not have $1.8 billion to pay Israel; if Israel wants the gas export contracts to be implemented, it must be willing to make some allowances,” said John Astrop, a senior source in the global gas and electricity market, after International Chamber of Commerce arbitrators ordered Egyptian gas companies to pay $1.76 billion compensation to Israel Electric Corporation (IEC) for the heavy damages it incurred after they stopped supplying gas.

In the months after Egyptian president Hosni Mubarak was overthrown, the country stopped the flow of natural gas to Israel following a string of attacks on the pipeline in the Sinai Peninsula and because it did not have sufficient reserves to answer the needs of the domestic market.

After the gas import deal collapsed, IEC was forced to procure more expensive fuels to generate electricity. IEC and EMG the owners of the pipeline sued the national oil and gas companies EGAS and EGPC for billions of dollars.

According to reports in the foreign press, the ruling ordered the Egyptian companies to also compensate EMG for $288 million.

“This is a very large sum of money for Egypt to pay, but it is a paltry figure when you compare it to the revenues Israel expects from exporting the gas from Tamar and Leviathan to Egypt,” claimed Astrop, “Which is why Israel cannot demand this sum immediately, unless it wants to wait ten years before Leviathan is developed.”

Astrop said Israel should offer Egypt a 15-20 year payment plan for the compensation. “The best way to do this would be to offer the Egyptian companies to pay a higher price for the gas they buy from Israel. This way, Egypt can accept the arbitrators’ order and not reinforce its image abroad as a country that does not respect agreements, while on the other hand Israel receives the money and is seen as a country that is willing to be flexible. It’s a win-win for both sides.”

“Despite Egypt’s announcement, there is still a strong indication that it will move forward with gas imports from Israel,” said Sir Michael Leigh, a senior fellow at the German Marshall Fund of the United States. He said the gas talks will resume the moment a solution is found for the legal dispute. He further added that the increasing demand for gas in Egypt justifies the import of Israeli gas even after the domestic Zohr discovery.

“The gas discovered in the Egyptian reservoir will be used for the local market, while the Israeli gas will be used for export from one of the country’s two liquefaction facilities,” he explained.

“Israel must not export the gas”

Former Shell president John Hofmeister disagrees with Astrop and Leigh. “Egypt’s announcement only reinforces the argument that Israel should not export the gas.” The export contracts to Egypt may benefit Israel on the diplomatic front, but Hofmeister said “they can also do the opposite.”

He argued the export deals have a duration of 15-20 years and Israel cannot actually guarantee to supply its neighboring countries for that long. “What if there is a war between Israel and Egypt? Will Israel still supply gas or will it break the agreement? What happens if there is a separate arbitration ruling and Egypt decides to stop importing gas? In these cases, the opposite of what Israel wants ends up occurring.”

Hofmeister, who has previously made such claims in interviews with “Globes”, said Israel should use the gas for its internal consumption and to assure its energy security. “I am not against exports, but long before that Israel should take to convert anything it can to gas whether it is transportation or manufacturing, power stations or homes. Energy is security, and security matters much more than money. Israel must correctly exploit the asset it discovered.”

A senior attorney in the global energy industry, who previously consulted both the Israeli and Egyptian governments, agrees with Hofmeister. “Instead of finding creative ways to export gas to Egypt, Israel should find conventional ways to increase gas consumption in its domestic market.” He claimed the likelihood of exporting gas to Egypt was low even before the arbitrators’ ruling and was even lower now.

“Whoever believes it will be possible to export gas to Egypt, at least in the next 7-8 years, clearly does not understand the global gas market,” he said, adding: “The arbitrators’ ruling was the worst thing that could have happened to Netanyahu on the way to approving the gas framework.”

He said Egypt’s decision to halt talks with Israel pulls the rug out from underneath the justification given to the government bypassing the antitrust authority that it was necessary for geopolitical, diplomatic reasons. His advice: prepare for an international lawsuit from Noble Energy. “The approval and implementation of the gas framework will be delayed, and Noble will not accept that.”

Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes-online.com - on December 10, 2015

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2015

Orit Strook  credit: Marc Israel Sellem/The Jerusalem Post Finance C'ttee approves NIS 300m coalition funds distribution

The money will mainly go to Religious Zionist party minister Orit Strook's Ministry of Settlements and National Missions.

Dangoor Academy  credit: British Embassy in Tel Aviv British Embassy showcases Israeli healthcare startups

The nine startups participated in the Dangoor HealthTech Academy, a program that connects Israeli startups with the UK healthcare system.

NextVision Stabilized Systems  credit: Shlomi Yosef/Tali Bogdanovsky Next Vision shareholders make NIS 230m exit

A British hedge fund has bought a 2.5% stake in the stabilized cameras company.

Energean CEO Mathios Rigas at the Israel Business Conference   credit: Shlomi Yosef Energean's $1b gas fields sale at risk

The sale of the energy company's asset portfolio in Egypt, Italy and Croatia may fall through because of the buyer's difficulties with the Italian regulator.

Kela Technologies founders Jason Manne, Hamutal Meridor, Alon Dror and Omer Bar Ilan  credit:  Yosef Haim Alterman Defense tech co Kela raises $39m

In response to the events of October 7, Kela has developed a platform for rapid integration of commercial technologies into military systems.

Benjamin Netanyahu  credit: ‎Alex Kolomoisky, Yediot Aharonot Firing the Shin Bet chief: The hurdles

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says he has "lost trust" in Shin Bet head Ronen Bar. Will this be enough to overcome legal challenges to his dismissal?

Emiliano Calemzuk  credit: PR CEO and "investor group" buying out Reshet 13

CEO Emiliano Calemzuk and the other investors will hold 74% of the television channel, while Len Blavatnik’s Access Industries and WBD will remain with 26%.

Inflation  credit: Tali Bogdanovsky Unexpectedly low February CPI reading cuts inflation

While inflation in Israel in the 12 months to the end of February 2025 is lower than forecast, housing prices continue to rise.

Yitzhak Tshuva credit: Gidon Levy and Tali Bogdanovsky Competition Authority allows Delek takeover of Isracard

The Competition Authority is considered the easier of the two regulatory hurdles that the deal must overcome, the other being the Supervisor of Banks.

David Amsalem  credit  Noam Moskowitz, Knesset Spokesperson's Office Rafael to pay state NIS 444m dividend

The minister in charge of the Government Companies Authority, David Amsalem, has approved the payment by the defense company.

Barak MX air defense system  credit: IAI IAI profit jumps 55%

Israel Aerospace Industries posted a net profit of $493 million for 2024, and ended the year with an all-time high orders backlog of $25 billion.

A TSG system in tactical use  credit: PR TSG signs cooperation agreement with US defense co

The agreement includes the integration of TSG's advanced technologies into sensor-based defense systems, which will be integrated into the operational systems of US defense units.

Bria CEO Yair Adato credit: Kseniia Poliak Israeli visual generative AI co Bria raises $40m

Bria’s Visual Generative AI platform empowers businesses to create predictable, controllable, and on-brand content that aligns with their visual language.

Amnon Shashua and Aviram Ziv credit: Eyal Izhar OrCam stymied by investor dispute with Shashua

Demands by institutional investors are blocking the visual and hearing impairment device developer's recovery plan.

Work on the Green Line credit: Bar Lavi Egged wins tender to operate TA light rail Purple, Green Lines

NTA awarded the tender to Egged, which already operates the Red Line, despite government ministry opposition to one operator for the entire network.

Gabi Seroussi illustration: Gil Gibli Board chooses Seroussi as IAI chair as Erdan freezes candidacy

Israel Aerospace Industries board chose Gabi Seroussi as chair even though he did not to go through the preliminary process of the Government Companies Authority appointments review committee.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018