Is the Lebanon deal wonderful or terrible?

Dr. Norman Bailey

Israel's maritime border agreement with Lebanon has met with extravagant praise and vituperative condemnation, but neither side is right.

After many years of off-and-on negotiations, Israel and Lebanon have finally reached a deal concerning their offshore waters and the gas fields under them. The deal, brokered by the US, has set off a firestorm of extreme criticism and equally extreme praise on the part of the Israeli commentariat.

The fact is that the deal is neither wonderful nor terrible, but rather the best that can be hoped for under the circumstances.

Much has been made by the critics that under the terms of the deal, Israel relinquished 860 square kilometers of its maximum demand. the critics overlook, however, the fact that Lebanon gave up 1,430 square kilometers of its extreme position. In other words, a compromise was struck, in which neither side got everything it wanted--the very definition of a compromise.

Additionally, five kilometers from shore Israel controls a security zone that otherwise would not be in its waters.

Israel gets the totality of the Karish field and the rights to 17% of the revenues from the Sidon field, otherwise under Lebanese control. The revenues will be received by the field's developer, the French company Total, and Lebanon's share will not be disbursed until Israel is paid its share.

Once the Sidon rig is completed by Total and is operating, Hezbollah loses all incentive to destroy the Israeli Karish rig, since Israel would immediately retaliate by destroying the Sidon rig.

One aspect of the agreement is questionable. Total will pay Lebanon's share of the Sidon earnings only to the Lebanese government, not to Hezbollah; however, since Hezbollah has effective control of Lebanon, it can undoubtedly force the government to turn over all or part of the payments.

All-in-all a reasonable agreement. The US is to be congratulated on its contribution to resolving a difficult problem in the Middle East, where the Biden administration's overall record is dismal.

Dr. Norman Bailey is professor of Economic Statecraft at the Galilee International Management Institute, and adjunct professor at the Institute of World Politics, Washington DC. Dr. Bailey was a senior staff member of the National Security Council during the Reagan administration and of the Office of the Director of National Intelligence during the George W. Bush administration.

Published by Globes, Israel business news - en.globes.co.il - on October 18, 2022.

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd., 2022.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Senseless

When even common courtesy is condemned by political partisans, we are seeing the real threat to Israel's future.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Stop shouting, start talking

The new government's actions and proposals are not ideal, but not the apocalypse either, and reasoned discourse should produce acceptable solutions.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli 2023 could be a tough diplomatic year for Israel

The war in Ukraine and growing unrest in Iran pose challenges for Israel but the biggest problem will be if Netanyahu is unable to restrain his right-wing coalition partners.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli A tale of two elections

Both elections will seriously affect the future trajectory of Israel and the US, as well as their relations with each other.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli How to stop Israel's endless elections

Restoring stability to Israel's political system requires a couple of fundamental reforms.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Is the Lebanon deal wonderful or terrible?

Israel's maritime border agreement with Lebanon has met with extravagant praise and vituperative condemnation, but neither side is right.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli In the new year, Israel's problems are mainly at home

The regional outlook is better than for some time, and internationally Israel is well positioned. The dangers lie in social divisions and political dysfunction.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli The PA: Time for Israeli intervention

With Iran's proxies threatening to take over the West Bank, Israel must act swiftly to replace failing Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Going soft on the regime likeliest to use nukes

Only one country has serious thoughts of triggering Armageddon, and it isn't Russia or China.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Reform the Israel Police

A string of recent incidents shows how ill-adapted Israel Police is to its task. It must change before things get out of hand.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Israel needs a constitution now

The current lack of accountability on the part of our politicians is putting the country's very survival at stake.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Give the people's wealth to the people

Israel's sovereign wealth fund, finally activated, should be used to narrow the country's shockingly wide economic gaps.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Israel Police clobbers public diplomacy

Israel has recently found effective PR responses to its enemies, but the reality of heavy-handed policing is undermining them.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Genocide is a word not to be used lightly

The Russian invasion of Ukraine is a crime under international law and atrocities have been committed, but the Russians are not trying to annihilate the Ukrainian people.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Will Israel's Arabs use their new-found power wisely?

If they do, it could well be to Israel's wider benefit.

Norman Bailey  illustration: Gil Gibli Ukraine: Gains for China, worries for Israel

Russia's invasion of Ukraine looks like another chapter in the rise of China and the waning of the US. As for Israel, its interests do not justify its ambivalence.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018