Why Israel is heading for a housing disaster

Dror Marmor

Clue: 181,000 babies were born in Israel in 2016, and 24,000 immigrants arrived.

While Minister of Finance Moshe Kahlon and Minister of Construction and Housing Yoav Galant counted 6,000 buyer's price lotteries in 2016 and celebrated 280 apartments for long-term rent in Herzliya, 181,000 babies were born in Israel. 5,000 couples married each month, and 1,000 couples divorced and presumably looked for another apartment for one ex-partner to live in. Meanwhile, 24,000 new immigrants arrived in Israel. Zionism.

A small country? 8,650,000 citizens live in Israel plus about 200,000 invisible illegal immigrants. Almost without feeling it, we have overtaken Austria and Switzerland.

The average fertility rate per woman in Israel is 3.13 children - the rate is the same for Jewish and Arab women, incidentally. In Austria, a woman gives birth to 1.9 children on average. In Switzerland, she makes do with 1.5. In those countries, they need fewer homes with each passing generation. Here, we need almost twice as many.

In another fifteen years, more than ten million Israelis will live here, while year after year we shall continue to measure housing starts in relation to the previous year's number or to the construction peaks of the glorious 1990s. Remember heroic Arik Sharon finding housing solutions for the million immigrants who arrived in Israel within a few years? In fifteen years' time, there will be a million more Israelis every five years.

But who thinks ahead? At best, we let an Excel spreadsheet calculate how many homes we'll need by 2040, and celebrate as though we can already live in them.

It isn't just homes. The technological revolution will not stop at mobile telephones or at automated cars. In five, ten or twenty years, will every worker need a 12 square meter room, when everyone's office is mainly in their smartphone?

Are the plans for more and more huge office towers and enclosed malls in Bnei Brak, Petah Tikva, Herzliya and Tel Aviv the dream of municipalities that want more municipal taxes, or has someone really stopped to think about a strategy for the coming years?

No-one dares change even the planning in the kibbutzim and moshavim. Seven and ten-acre holdings continue to be sold, and parents are still forced to choose one child who will stay in the settlement, when in any case no farmer can make a living out of less than 250 acres.

In this way we pass all the big problems on from one generation to the next. Meanwhile, we create instant solutions to fill holes. A real long-term strategy? Apparently we're good at that only when it comes to procuring submarines that we might need in another decade or two. But then, maybe it's really best to bury our heads 20,000 leagues under the sea.

Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes-online.com - on February 26, 2017

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2017

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Bank of Israel admits failure to tame inflation

In the announcement on its latest interest rate hike, the Bank of Israel acknowledges that it does not have the ability to control inflation.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli A political Chief Statistician? Too scary to think about

Netanyahu's attempt to appoint a crony to head the Central Bureau of Statistics threatens to sap confidence in the economy.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Forecasting is for fools

The market has already priced in the expected and nobody foresees the unexpected, which is maybe why economists so often get their predictions badly wrong.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Diaspora homebuyers are foreigners

Bottom line, your nation's poor come before the rich people of another country.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Netanyahu won't anger US on settlements

For Housing Minister Uri Ariel, the current housing shortage supersedes attempts to reach peace with the Palestinians and the Americans.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Who is buying Israeli homes?

Nationwide foreign residents account for a negligible number of purchases but in some Jerusalem neighborhoods they account for 40% of purchases.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Housing Minister makes pointless promises

Uri Ariel has realized all to quickly that the power of the housing minister in Israel is mostly in pompous and populist statements to the media.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Burst the housing bubble now

Instead of initiating another lost decade and falling home prices (prices fell 22% in real terms in 1998-2007), it would be better to slash prices all at once.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Banks control the real estate market

It is the banks which are the biggest player on the field in the capital intensive real estate industry.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Fischer erred badly on housing prices

Since 2005, when Fischer took up his post, housing prices in Israel have risen 70%.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Fischer to stop the home buying stampede

Stanley Fischer is continuing to make efforts to cut spiraling real estate prices.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Reality will be stronger than the housing law

In a falling market, few will want to take advantage of the streamlined planning procedures.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Aspirin instead of antibiotics

Vested interests will thwart Netanyahu's treatment for the sick housing market, while the real ills remain without a cure.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli Tell us the truth about home prices

The answer to the question whether prices are rising or falling depends on who's paying for it.

Dror Marmor  illustration: Gil Gibli The housing plan: good for now, but…

Without long-term plans to meet Israel's land and housing needs, the shortage will persist.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018