OECD & IMF: Israel has West's worst traffic jams

Traffic jam Photo: Eyal Yitzhar
Traffic jam Photo: Eyal Yitzhar

IMF assistant director Craig Beaumont: Israel suffers the worst congestion in the OECD, and the situation will unfortunately only get worse. 

In-depth reports about the Israeli economy published by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) and the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the world's two most authoritative economic research institutions, reached exactly the same conclusion: road congestion in Israel is the country's number one problem in comparison with other developed countries.

The figures have been familiar to decision-makers in Israel for a long time. Action to redress the problem has begun, but what is being done is too little and too late. Traffic jams do not interest Minister of Finance Moshe Kahlon. Ministry of Transport Yisrael Katz is doing something, but is preventing implementation of several of the most effective ways of reducing congestion, because these are liable to harm him politically.

"Israel suffers the worst congestion in the OECD, and the situation will unfortunately only get worse," IMF assistant director Craig Beaumont, declared at a press conference summing up an IMF delegation's visit to Israel. "The population in Israel is increasing, the standing of living is increasing, more and more people are switching to private vehicles, and the infrastructure challenge is mounting."

Three days earlier, a bi-annual OECD report presented figures highlighting the severity of the problem. Transportation density in Israel averages 2,800 vehicles per kilometer of roads, 3.5 times the 800 vehicles per kilometer of roads average density in the OECD and almost double the average density of 1,300 vehicles per kilometer of roads in Spain, which has the second worst road density in the OECD after Israel.

The international comparison arouses a shudder, but the government was aware of the problem even without the OECD comparison. The Ministry of Finance recently revised its estimate of the economic damage caused by road congestion from NIS 25 billion to NIS 35 billion.

The reason is simple: the pace of construction in mass transit infrastructure is far from overtaking the place of increase in the number of private vehicles. Last month, "Globes" reported the findings of a probe by the Knesset Research and Information Center showing that the number of vehicles in Israel increased by 17% in the past five years, while the road area rose by only 6%. A strategic plan by the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Transport from 2012 estimated that NIS 200-300 billion in investment would be needed over the coming decade in order to close the gap in mass transit infrastructure between the large cities in Israel and Europe. In contrast to Europe, however, the population is growing rapidly and the standard of living is constantly rising, meaning that Israel must run in order to stay in the same place.

The next example shows just how hopeless the government's effort to augment infrastructure in order to cope with the increase in the number of vehicles is. The largest mass transit project currently under construction in Israel is the Tel Aviv Light Rail red line. This NIS 20 billion project, slated for completion in 2022, is designed to remove 50,000 vehicles from the roads. The problem is that the number of vehicles on the roads rose by 150,000 just in 2017. This means that three light rail lines will be needed to preserve the current density ratio.

What can be done? As Beamont explained, much can be done - if we want to do it. "It will take a long time to close the infrastructure gap created as a result of many years of neglect. As an interim solution, we therefore recommend a policy based on managing demand - for example, shared transportation, car pools, and public transportation lanes. All of these are relatively cheap and have a quick effect. A more significant step will be following the example of London and Stockholm by imposing a congestion fee."

The term "congestion fee" is taboo in Israel because of one man: Yisrael Katz. He is unwilling to accept a congestion tax at the entrance to Tel Aviv, even though all transportation experts believe that this measure is essential and very effective.

Katz's argument is that it is unfair to punish drivers by forcing them to leave their private vehicles without giving them a suitable public transportation alternative. The real reason, however, is political ambition, not fairness. Katz knows that he will pay for a congestion fee at the ballot box, and is unwilling to put his neck on the chopping block, with all due respect to the never-ending traffic jams. Only after efforts at persuasion by the Ministry of Finance, the Bank of Israel, and a long list of experts did Katz allow a trial venture offering monetary prizes to drivers refraining from driving during peak congestion hours. That is at least something.

If a congestion fee cannot be introduced because of Katz's political agenda, however, what about shared transportation and public transportation lanes? These means are also being instituted in slow and incomplete fashion because of political considerations and bureaucratic indifference.

The Ministry of Transport's "City to City" plan was designed to add 330,000 kilometers of public transportation lanes in 20 cities in the Greater Tel Aviv metropolis. The plan has been implemented in only three cities to date, because the local authorities are fearful of the response by drivers of private vehicles to the expropriation of existing lanes for public transportation.

Published by Globes [online], Israel Business News - www.globes-online.com - on March 14, 2018

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2018

Traffic jam Photo: Eyal Yitzhar
Traffic jam Photo: Eyal Yitzhar
groundcover founders credit: Yossi Yarom Israeli observability co groundcover raises $35m

groundcover has developed a “Bring Your Own Cloud” (BYOC) observability solution, redefining the architecture of a modern observability platform.

Tel Aviv Stock Exchange credit: Shutterstock MagioreStock Foreign investment in TASE hits five-year high

Foreign investors have been flocking to the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange in recent weeks, the TASE research department tells "Globes."

Elbit Systems tank turret systems credit: Elbit Systems Elbit Systems wins $100m tank turret systems deal

The Israel defense electronics company will supply its advanced UT30 MK2 unmanned turret systems to General Dynamics European Land Systems (GDELS) to be supplied to a NATO European country.

Tomer Weingarten Photo: PR Trump targets SentinelOne exec in act of revenge

The US administration has suspended the security clearance of the company's chef intelligence and public policy officer Chris Krebs and everyone associated with him.

Tel Aviv Stock Exchange share prices rising credit: Tali Bogdanovsky TASE opens sharply higher after Trump U-turn on tariffs

The pause is being interpreted as a climb down after US President Donald Trump admitted he had made the move to calm the markets.

Ashot Ashkelon credit: Ministry of Defense Up 250%, Ashot Ashkelon wins another Defense Ministry order

The Israeli defense company's share price has risen 250% in the past three years since FIMI Opportunity Funds acquired control.

Liad Agmon credit: Eyal Izhar Insight Partners Liad Agmon steps down as managing partner

Serial entrepreneur Agmon has served as a partner at Insight Partners Israel alongside Daniel Aronovitz who set up the Israel office.

Shekels credit: Shutterstock Vladerina32 Shekel slide resumes amid escalating tariff war

The Bank of Israel is not expected to intervene in the forex market despite the sharp depreciation of the shekel.

Nir Zuk credit: Inbal Marmari Palo Alto Networks mulls buying AI security co for $700m

Sources inform "Globes" that on Palo Alto's radar is Protect AI.

President Donald Trump hosts Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu credit: Reuters Kevin Mohatt Israeli officials confident on US tariff concessions

Senior Israeli figures believe that concessions could be tied to progress on strategic regional political issues that are important to President Trump.

Phoenix Investment House CEO Avner Hadad  credit: Tommy Harpaz "The market has priced in all the bad things"

Phoenix Investment House CEO Avner Hadad says US markets could continue to fall, but that we are close to interesting territory for patient investors.

Tel Aviv credit: Shutterstock Tel Aviv slips in World's Wealthiest Cities ranking

Tel Aviv's position as one of the world's wealthiest cities took a big knock over the past year as it slipped from 42nd to 48th in investment advisors Henley & Co.'s "World's Wealthiest Cities" Top 50 ranking.

Leviathan platform  credit: Albatross C'ttee seen recommending no cut in gas exports

The Dayan committee on the future of the gas sector estimates that Israel's natural gas reserves will run out in 2045.

Accountant General Yali Rothenberg credit: Rafi Kutz Israel's fiscal deficit continues to narrow

The deficit narrowed in the twelve months to the end of March 2025, for the sixth consecutive month, Ministry of Finance accountant general Yali Rothenberg reported today.

Arkia credit: Arkia Arkia cuts Tel Aviv - New York April fares

Arkia has cut fares at the last minute, a time when prices usually soar even higher, according to the pricing method used in the industry.

Bank of Israel Governor Prof. Amir Yaron credit: Dani Shem Tov Knesset Spokesperson BoI Governor: US tariffs could push up inflation in Israel

Prof. Amir Yaron tells "Globes" that there is a risk that the new tariffs will cause inflation to rise in the US, with a knock-on effect for Israel.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018