State wins Israel Chemicals royalties arbitration

The decision could be worth NIS 2.5 billion to the state up to 2030.

The state has won a victory against Dead Sea Works of the Israel Chemicals Ltd. (TASE: ICL) group. At the end of the first stage of the arbitration proceedings between Israel Chemicals and the State of Israel, the panel of arbitrators decided that Israel Chemicals has to pay the state royalties for the past use of minerals it extracts from the Dead Sea and other sites that are natural resources belonging to the state. The decision was by a majority. Supreme Court judge (emeritus) Tova Strassberg-Cohen and Adv. Alex Hartman sided with the state, while Adv. Ram Caspi sided with the company. The amount that Israel Chemicals will have to pay is yet to be set.

Legal experts estimated today that, in the wake of the arbitrators' decision, up to 2030, when its concession for mining at the Dead Sea expires, Israel Chemicals will have to pay the state some NIS 2.5 billion.

The state demanded that Israel Chemical should pay royalties amounting to $291 million for the period from 2000 to the date the claim was filed, March 2011. A substantial portion of the claim related to bromine-based products from minerals that the company extracted at Ramat Hovav. The state argued that these were products on which Israel Chemicals owed royalties that it had avoided paying for years, even though its managers were aware of the matter and had expressed concern at board discussions that a claim might arise.

Israel Chemical argued that the state itself had exempted it in the past from paying royalties when it privatized the company and sold it to Shaul Eisenberg.

The dispute between Israel Chemicals and the state hinged on the question whether Dead Sea Works was obliged to pay royalties to the state on derivative products produced by companies in the group with plants located outside the Dead Sea area. The state argued that by virtue of the fact that these companies were part of a concern that represented a single economic entity, Dead Sea Works had to pay royalties on the derivative products that they produced, and that the geographic location of the plants had no bearing on matter.

Dead Sea Works argued that it was liable to pay royalties on derivative products only if the plants concerned were located in the Dead Sea area.

Strassberg-Cohen and Hartman accepted the state's argument. "Common sense, legal logic, and economic logic, as well as the purpose of the concession, are inconsistent with a situation in which if a compounds plant of the concern is located at the Dead Sea, Dead Sea Works pays royalties on its products, but if it is located a few meters away, Dead Sea Works will be exempt from paying royalties." Strassberg-Cohen said that Dead Sea Works' geographic approach distorted the delicate balance between its interest and the public interest.

Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes-online.com - on May 19, 2014

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2013

groundcover founders credit: Yossi Yarom Israeli observability co groundcover raises $35m

groundcover has developed a “Bring Your Own Cloud” (BYOC) observability solution, redefining the architecture of a modern observability platform.

Tel Aviv Stock Exchange credit: Shutterstock MagioreStock Foreign investment in TASE hits five-year high

Foreign investors have been flocking to the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange in recent weeks, the TASE research department tells "Globes."

Elbit Systems tank turret systems credit: Elbit Systems Elbit Systems wins $100m tank turret systems deal

The Israel defense electronics company will supply its advanced UT30 MK2 unmanned turret systems to General Dynamics European Land Systems (GDELS) to be supplied to a NATO European country.

Tomer Weingarten Photo: PR Trump targets SentinelOne exec in act of revenge

The US administration has suspended the security clearance of the company's chef intelligence and public policy officer Chris Krebs and everyone associated with him.

Tel Aviv Stock Exchange share prices rising credit: Tali Bogdanovsky TASE opens sharply higher after Trump U-turn on tariffs

The pause is being interpreted as a climb down after US President Donald Trump admitted he had made the move to calm the markets.

Ashot Ashkelon credit: Ministry of Defense Up 250%, Ashot Ashkelon wins another Defense Ministry order

The Israeli defense company's share price has risen 250% in the past three years since FIMI Opportunity Funds acquired control.

Liad Agmon credit: Eyal Izhar Insight Partners Liad Agmon steps down as managing partner

Serial entrepreneur Agmon has served as a partner at Insight Partners Israel alongside Daniel Aronovitz who set up the Israel office.

Shekels credit: Shutterstock Vladerina32 Shekel slide resumes amid escalating tariff war

The Bank of Israel is not expected to intervene in the forex market despite the sharp depreciation of the shekel.

Nir Zuk credit: Inbal Marmari Palo Alto Networks mulls buying AI security co for $700m

Sources inform "Globes" that on Palo Alto's radar is Protect AI.

President Donald Trump hosts Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu credit: Reuters Kevin Mohatt Israeli officials confident on US tariff concessions

Senior Israeli figures believe that concessions could be tied to progress on strategic regional political issues that are important to President Trump.

Phoenix Investment House CEO Avner Hadad  credit: Tommy Harpaz "The market has priced in all the bad things"

Phoenix Investment House CEO Avner Hadad says US markets could continue to fall, but that we are close to interesting territory for patient investors.

Tel Aviv credit: Shutterstock Tel Aviv slips in World's Wealthiest Cities ranking

Tel Aviv's position as one of the world's wealthiest cities took a big knock over the past year as it slipped from 42nd to 48th in investment advisors Henley & Co.'s "World's Wealthiest Cities" Top 50 ranking.

Leviathan platform  credit: Albatross C'ttee seen recommending no cut in gas exports

The Dayan committee on the future of the gas sector estimates that Israel's natural gas reserves will run out in 2045.

Accountant General Yali Rothenberg credit: Rafi Kutz Israel's fiscal deficit continues to narrow

The deficit narrowed in the twelve months to the end of March 2025, for the sixth consecutive month, Ministry of Finance accountant general Yali Rothenberg reported today.

Arkia credit: Arkia Arkia cuts Tel Aviv - New York April fares

Arkia has cut fares at the last minute, a time when prices usually soar even higher, according to the pricing method used in the industry.

Bank of Israel Governor Prof. Amir Yaron credit: Dani Shem Tov Knesset Spokesperson BoI Governor: US tariffs could push up inflation in Israel

Prof. Amir Yaron tells "Globes" that there is a risk that the new tariffs will cause inflation to rise in the US, with a knock-on effect for Israel.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018