Court approves class action on alleged Plus500 manipulation

Plus500
Plus500

The Tel Aviv District Court has not accepted the Israeli online trading firm's explanation of its pause mechanism and ordered Plus500 to provide details on all pauses in the past seven years.

The Tel Aviv District Court has granted approval to litigate on a class action suit against Plus500 Israel, a subsidiary of global online trading services company Plus500 (LSE: PLUS), which is headquartered in Israel and has a market cap of £1.4 billion on the London Stock Exchange. Plus500 operates its online trading services in 32 languages allowing users to buy financial instruments in currencies, commodities and the indices of stock exchanges worldwide in real time.

In June 2016 Asher Torgeman bought put options on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange DAX index for €1,000 in the belief that in contradiction to the polls, the British would vote for Brexit in the UK referendum, thus causing European stock markets to fall. When the results showed that Brexit had prevailed, he asked to sell the options but was told he could not make the sell.

In response, Plus500 told Torgeman that following the UK referendum, "The German 30 instrument and all the options for that instrument were not available for trading because of the very high volatility in the market, which had created larger margins than usual …….. and that created high risk for traders. Accordingly, Plus500 had taken action to reduce this risk."

Protecting customers?

Torgeman filed his suit through Adv. Hanoch Ehrlich of the Hadah Roth Shenhar Helfer & Co. law firm for approval to conduct a class action. In the request, it was claimed that trading was paused for 90 minutes only for those asking to sell put options. Although at the same time, trading in financial instruments that moved in the opposite direction - call options - and had fallen 76.51% continued as usual even though they were also based on the DAX. According to Torgeman, Plus500 did not renew options trading for 90 minutes, which violates many clauses in the Securities Law, and the aim was to prevent Plus500 from making losses.

Plus500 claimed that the pause in trade is a mechanism, automatically operated in real time according to pre-determined criteria, which is designed first and foremost to protect customers. Plus500 also claimed that the mechanism operates symmetrically for both selling and buying of financial instruments regardless of the loss or profit at the time that the pause mechanism is operated. Plus500 attached an expert opinion from Prof. Avner Kalay, an expert in capital market trading and finance.

Judge Magen Altuvia dismissed the company's claim that this was an automatically operated defense mechanism. He said, "The work automatic should not be used to remove responsibility as if the act was not carried out by the company." He added, "Plus500 is responsible for programming the automatic software and feeds in the parameters for these pauses. It is up to it to prove that during the hour of the pause that it was designed for the benefit of its customers."

Previous indications

The judge also ruled that, "It is not possible to say that the volatility on DAX based assets or options took place without warning or previous indications. Even if there was extreme volatility in the rate of options or basic assets, it would seem, that the company was not entitled to pause the trading."

Judge Altuvia added that Plus500 ignored the fact, as documented by the plaintiff, that it was not possible to trade in put options but was able to trade in call options. "Even though this was a financial instrument that was traded with a fall of 76.51%, that is to say a larger loss of tens of percentage points for customers who bought it before the results of the referendum was published."

A violation of Securities Law

In light of this, Judge Altuvia wrote that contrary to the claims by Plus500 that the pause in trading and its non resumption, were only taken to protect customers, "It seems that the decisions to pause trading were not symmetrical and on the face of it at this stage and it seems that they worked for the benefit of the company."

Judge Altuvia added, "On the face of it at this stage, and despite the explanations attempted by Plus500 CEO Yevgeni Schtuckmeyster, to provide as part of the investigation about the way the risk management team works, it doesn't seem that there was a reasonable cause to differentiate between financial instruments based on the same asset."

Judge Altuvia pointed out that Plus500's experts, who cla8med that the pause in trading was symmetrical, di not check at all what had happened in practice when there was a pause of trading on that day in June 2016 and that the opinion was not based the company's data and they had not even seen how the company's trading pause operated.

Altuvia also wrote that, "It seems that the risk management team stopping and resuming trading in the market arena is tainted with a conflict of interests.." The court added and ruled that there is something reasonable in the statement that trading contravened the Securities Law while violating other laws.

At the end of his decision, Judge Altuvia wrote that although only discussed stopping options trading from June 24 2016 and there are no details about other pauses in trade and their circumstances, "Even so the aforementioned event in which the pause and the non-pause in trade were 'caught' at the same time raises apparent concerns about the conduct of the company and is automatic and manual trading pause mechanism. It is up to the company to present as requested within 30 days details of the pauses in trade that occurred over the past seven years prior to submission of the request, their amount, and details of deals that were blocked and the reason that they took place."

Adv. Ehrlich said, "This is a dramatic ruling after the plaintiff clearly proved how Plus50 manipulates trading in order to prevent its customers from profiting, especially in the specific circumstances of this incident because the day after the Brexit referendum was one of the busiest days on the world's capital markets and Plus500 paused trading for 90 minutes in the most dramatic hours on that day and did so only for customers making a profit. The ruling has local and international significance because Plus500 is a huge international conglomerate with branches worldwide managed by virtual trading in a similar way (subject to local regulation). We estimate that now in according with the court's decision we can receive real data regarding the event that is the subject of the lawsuit and for events over the past seven years.

Published by Globes, Israel business news - en.globes.co.il - on October 25, 2021.

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd., 2021.

Israeli startup gems 2022 Globes names Finout "Most Promising Startup of 2025"

Cloud cost management solutions company Finout tops the list of Israeli startups most likely to succeed named by 80 local and foreign funds.

Mobileye CEO Amnon Shashua credit: Heinz Troll European Patent Office Mobileye posts strong Q1, reaffirms guidance despite tariffs

The Israeli advanced driving assistance systems company beat analysts' expectations on revenue and met expectations on non-GAAP net profit.

Xtend drones credit: Xtend Sentrycs teams with Xtend to strengthen drone security

The aim of the all-Israeli collaboration is to create a synergy of proven capabilities in a world where drones have become a major threat.

Intel Haifa  credit: Shutterstock Intel layoffs in Israel will benefit rivals

Industry experts agree that Intel staff dismissed in Israel will have no trouble finding work at rivals like Nvidia, as happened during last year's layoffs.

Ministry of Finance Jerusalem credit: Shutterstock Treasury sees Trump's tariffs cutting Israel's GDP growth

Amid the uncertainty that still surrounds the level of tariffs that would ultimately be imposed on Israeli goods, the annual damage to growth is estimated by the Finance Ministry at less than 0.5% of GDP.

French President Emmanuel Macron at the Paris Air Show in 2023 credit: Reuters Israel to scale down Paris Air Show presence

Due to President Emmanuel Macron's antagonism, Israel is reducing its presence at the exhibition, Ministry of Defense International Defense Cooperation Directorate (SIBAT) head Yair Kulas tells "Globes."

Jerusalem court cmplex credit: Zarhy Architects Tenders issued for two huge Jerusalem construction projects

The PFI tenders for the Gan Hotzvim tech campus and the courts complex include grants of NIS 1.7 billion for the winning bidders.

Israel Innovation Authority CEO Dror Bin Innovation Authority chief: Israel top for deep tech investment

Dror Bin told the Globes TECH IL conference that deep tech is the next wave for global tech and the rate of investment in Israel is the world's highest.

Gil Shwed and Nadav Zafrir credit: Menash Cohen With new CEO Check Point beats analysts in Q1

Revenue rose 6.5% and GAAP net profit rose 5% in Nadav Zafrir's first full quarter at the helm.

Tel Aviv light rail credit: Yossi Cohen Rishon Lezion to finance Red Line light rail extension

The Rishon Lezion Municipality will pay for part of the extension by marketing land above the planned underground depot.

Intel Haifa development center credit: Shutterstock Intel to cut 20% of workforce - report

"Bloomberg" reports that new CEO Lip-Bu Tan will announce the layoffs this week.

Healthee team credit: Healthee PR AI healthcare costs management co Healthee raises $50m

Healthee’s benefits and care navigation platform empowers employees and employers to make the most of their health benefits.

Former Shufersal CEO Itzik Abercohen credit: Eyal Izhar Competition Authority summons former Shufersal CEO to hearing

According to the indictment, Shufersal and Itzik Abercohen allegedly made public statements through which he attempted to reach arrangements to raise prices.

Reco founders Ofer Klein, Gal Nakash, and Tal Shapira credit: Elegant Photographics Israeli SaaS security co Reco raises $25m

The Tel Aviv-based company has developed a comprehensive application discovery engine capable of identifying and classifying over 50,000 applications, and providing visibility into an organization’s SaaS ecosystem.

Tel Aviv Stock Exchange credit: Tali Bogdanovsky TASE outperforms global markets in 2025

Boosted by the strong results of Israel's banks, the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange has demonstrated impressive resilience to domestic and foreign upheavals.

Metro credit: Bar Lavi Can Hyundai fill Metro vacuum created by China's exclusion?

The South Korean giant is reportedly eager to enter Israel's infrastructure sector but may not have the resources to dig the Metro tunnels.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018