Ukraine war refugees skew Israel's migration figures

Ben Gurion Airport  credit: Shutterstock
Ben Gurion Airport credit: Shutterstock

Many who left Israel in 2023 were recent arrivals from Ukraine and Russia - but even without them there was a large exit of the young and educated.

Some 82,700 Israelis left Israel in 2023, considerably more than in 2022, and twice as many as in the years before that, according to the latest published migration figures. Closer examination of the data reveals, however, that many of those who left were immigrants from Russia and Ukraine who apparently came to Israel because of the war and the extensive draft in both countries.

Removing them from the statistics gives a somewhat brighter picture, but the numbers are still significantly higher than in the past. Is this a sign of things to come? It’s too early to say.

How do we know if someone has left Israel?

The migration data for Israel are subject both to objective methodological difficulties, and to exploitation for political purpose as statistics in a vacuum. In order to understand what migration to and from Israel really looks like, it’s necessary first of all to understand how the statistics are compiled.

When a person flies abroad, it’s not possible to know without thorough questioning what his aim is and when, if at all, he plans to return. Sometimes the person himself doesn’t know how permanent his stay away from the country will be. The definition used by the Central Bureau of Statistics is therefore a retrospective test. Anyone who has travelled abroad and not returned after a year is considered to have left.

In 2024, the Central Bureau of Statistics changed the definition of leaving Israel. Until then, a stay of 365 consecutive days overseas was required to classify a person as having left, but a study by the Bureau found that this count was not reliable, since sometimes home visits interrupted the sequence and prevented a person from being classified as having left even though this was clearly the case. Therefore, in an attempt to adopt globally accepted standards, the Bureau announced last year that it was switching "from a consecutive approach to an approach that allows for short visits" such that the overseas stay required was shortened to 275 days (not necessarily consecutive) during the year to the date of the check.

Even after the change, it is still only possible to know with a delay of a year what the migration numbers were during a given period. The migration figures for 2024 that were presented by the Central Bureau of Statistics at its annual conference late last month actually relate to 2023. We shall only receive full statistics for 2024 at the end of 2025. So, for the sake of clarity, from here onwards we shall refer to the figures in accordance with the period to which they relate, and not when they were released.

Two major events occurred in 2023: the government’s promotion of its judicial overhaul program, which raised many fears and turned emigration into a matter of public discussion; and the start of the war in October of that year.

October 2023 was particularly extreme for emigration, following the attack by Hamas and the opening of hostilities, and the balance of migration reached 12,600 net leavers (with fewer Israelis returning that month), which compares with a negative balance of just 1,300 in October 2022. But these numbers, high though they are, cannot explain the sharp rise in the number of leavers in the year as a whole, which totaled 59,000, which compares with 27,500 in 2022. Even before the war broke out, emigration was unusually high.

So what can explain the numbers? At least in part, the explanation lies in events only indirectly connected to Israel. In February 2022, Russia invaded Ukraine, and many were forced to flee the war zones. Ukraine announced extensive conscription, and in September 2022 Russia announced a partial call-up of reserves to fill the ranks following the failure of the initial assault. In addition, the economic situation in Russia deteriorated. Millions fled both countries to any destination possible, and people entitled to do so under the Law of Return came to Israel. Thus in 2022 the balance of migration to and from Israel was 81,200 more arrivals than departures, up from 30,200 in 2021.

From the latest figures it now emerges that many of these people chose not to remain in Israel for long, and left the following year, apparently for other Western countries. Of the 82,700 leavers in 2023, 26,300 were new immigrants who had arrived in Israel in the preceding two years, most of them from Russia and Ukraine.

If we exclude departing immigrants from the calculation, we find that the balance of international migration turns from minus 18,800 to plus 8,000, not nearly as bad as might have been thought. Nevertheless, we should not rejoice too soon: between 2010 and 2021, the positive migration balance was 16,600-38,100 annually. So even without the departing immigrants, there was a considerable shift, partly because of the effects of the war, and partly because of other circumstances that arose in 2023.

Young and educated: What characterizes the leavers?

A deeper look at the figures shows that those who leave are preponderantly young people at the start of their careers, with people aged 20-40 accounting for 40% of the total, while their proportion in the population as a whole is just 27%. Residents of the center and Tel Aviv account for a substantial proportion of the leavers, again higher than their proportion in the population as a whole. The northern and southern regions and Judea and Samaria are under-represented among those leaving the country, while for Jerusalem and Haifa the representation is fairly close to their proportions in the population.

As far as education is concerned, 53.7% of those who leave Israel have thirteen or more years of study, which compares with 45.2% in the general population. On the whole, then, the leavers are young, relatively well-educated and mobile, with a high chance of succeeding in careers overseas, and for whom it’s worth taking the risk of emigrating to a new country.

To sum up, matters in Israel are, as usual, complicated. There is indeed a large exodus, but attention needs to be paid to who is leaving and why. Nevertheless, the situation in 2023 was much worse than in a normal year. What happened in 2024? We shall discover that only at the end of 2025.

Published by Globes, Israel business news - en.globes.co.il - on March 10, 2025.

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd., 2025.

Ben Gurion Airport  credit: Shutterstock
Ben Gurion Airport credit: Shutterstock
Commuter jam credit: Eyal Izhar Israeli commuters impose 45 minute limit

Data show that employees would rather change jobs than travel longer, so companies with fast public transport access find it easiest to hire.

Intel's 2025 vision credit: Intel Will Intel's sell-off include Israeli assets?

After the sale of Altera, "Globes" considers whether the troubled chipmaker will sell Mobileye or its Kiryat Gat fab.

CloudShare management team credit: PR Bow River Capital buys Israeli co CloudShare

The Denver-based alternative asset manager is paying an estimated $60-80 million for the SaaS provider of AI guided solutions for complex technical training requirements.

Housing prices continue to rise   credit: Tali Bogdanovsky Israel's housing price rise riddle

Despite a huge inventory of unsold new homes in central Israel and weak sales, apartment prices are still rising. "Globes" analyzes the data.

Inflation  credit: Tali Bogdanovsky March CPI higher than expected, housing prices rise

The March reading brings annual inflation in Israel down to 3.3% from 3.4% at the end of February.

Ben Gurion airport credit: Tali Bogdanovsky Abundance of affordable last minute Passover flight deals

The return of foreign airlines to Israel has brought down fares dramatically even for last minute vacations.

Karish rig  credit: Eyal Izhar Kesem Energy signs gas deals worth $2.8b

The power plant, scheduled to begin operating in 2029, will buy gas worth $2 billion from Energean and a further $700-800 million from the Tamar partners.

Kosher for Passover Coca Cola bottles credit: social media Why are yellow cap Coca Cola bottles different from all others?

Nostalgic Coca Cola aficionados claim that the kosher for Passover version, made from sugar cane instead of high fructose corn syrup, is the genuine taste of the soft drink.

Avigdor Willenz credit: Intel Exclusive: Avigdor Willenz's Element Labs raises $50m

The Israeli startup is developing AI processors for inference, the stage in which AI models are activated after they have already been trained.

Ilya Sutskever credit: Cadya Levy SSI hiring dozens in Israel

AI company Safe Superintelligence is hiring many dozens of people in Tel Aviv, "Globes" has learned.

Johny Srouji credit: Amos Ben Gershom GPO Apple SVP leads senior delegation of execs to Israel

Jony Srouji: I am always filled with renewed energy and optimism about our shared achievements when I visit our R&D centers here.

Israeli apartments Credit: Shutterstock Apartments sold and rented

A selection of recent real estate deals in Israel in Tel Aviv, Ramat Gan, Petah Tikva, Givat Shmuel, Tiberias and Dimona.

Infinity Tower Tel Aviv credit: Courtesy Hagag Group French investors buy 2 Tel Aviv apartments for NIS 27.5m

The two apartments are in Hagag Group's Infinity Tower in the Summeil district.

El Al plane credit: Shutterstock El Al receives state approval to distribute dividend

The Israeli airline has now announced that it will be able to distribute up to 30% of net profit in 2025 and up to 40% in 2026-2028.

groundcover founders credit: Yossi Yarom Israeli observability co groundcover raises $35m

groundcover has developed a “Bring Your Own Cloud” (BYOC) observability solution, redefining the architecture of a modern observability platform.

Tel Aviv Stock Exchange credit: Shutterstock MagioreStock Foreign investment in TASE hits five-year high

Foreign investors have been flocking to the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange in recent weeks, the TASE research department tells "Globes."

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס Israel Business Conference 2018